Double Jeopardy: The Roles of Job Autonomy and Spousal Gender Ideology in Employed Women’s Mental Health

Abstract

Employed women persistently suffer in mental health despite more family-friendly workplaces. The job demand-control theory argues that employed women’s mental health depends on their job autonomy, while sociological research on the gender division of household labor locates the cause in how much they are expected by husbands to contribute to housework. The article integrates the two streams of literature by arguing that employed women’s job autonomy and their spousal gender ideology interact to shape their mental health. Using nationally representative household-level panel survey and fixed effects models, the study showed that job autonomy improved employed women’s mental health, but the benefits depended on their spousal gender ideologies. Specifically, women suffered a “double jeopardy” in mental health when they lacked job autonomy and had traditional husbands. In contrast, when women’s husbands had an egalitarian gender ideology, they enjoyed mental health regardless of job autonomy. In addition, women’s self-gender ideology did not predict their own or their husbands’ mental health. The results point to a societal-level change in men’s gender ideology as a fundamental way to improve employed women’s family well-being. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11482-022-10090-8.

National survey of mental health and life satisfaction of gig workers: the role of loneliness and financial precarity

“… 44 Public health, labour and social policies should address the loneliness and mental health burden in the freelance and informal economy especially during the pandemic and promote social support from other domains such as family and community. 45 …”

“…Alternative work arrangements and the latent benefits of employment need to be included in population mental health and health inequity research 44. Public health, labour and social policies should address the loneliness and mental health burden in the freelance and informal economy especially during the pandemic and promote social support from other domains such as family and community 45…”

Who Gains Mental Health Benefits from Work Autonomy? The Roles of Gender and Occupational Class

“…In addition, female employees in higher occupational groups might have more bargaining resources in the division of housework (Kan & He, 2018 ) and be able to pay for the childcare and housework services, thereby having more options and abilities to juggle work and life when using work autonomy. Thus, work autonomy might not be able to improve the mental health of female employees in the lower occupational groups due to the fact that they are suffering double jeopardy (Wang & Li, 2022 ). They not only have less work autonomy than higher occupational groups but also suffer more potential adverse effects of work autonomy.…”

“…This is because men in the higher occupational classes are more likely to be restricted by the work devotion schema, thereby being willing to work more in exchange for employers’ rewards (work autonomy) (Bathini & Kandathil, 2019 ). However, a stream of the latest research indicates that it might be job quality rather than job quantity that is important for workers’ mental health (Wang et al 2022a ; Wang & Li, 2022 ). Specifically, job quality and the discrepancy between actual and preferred working hours (termed as working time mismatches) can be more important in predicting workers’ mental health status than actual working hours (Golden & Gebreselassie, 2007 ; Kamerāde et al, 2019 ).…”

Using machine learning to estimate the incidence rate of intimate partner violence

“…Respondents' propensity to report IPV is associated with their gender ideology. A more patriarchal ideology holds that men are more capable than women and therefore men should predominate in roles of leadership and authority [35][36][37] . Consequently, men and women who hold a patriarchal gender ideology are more likely to conceal having experienced IPV: men due to fear of stigma 38 , while women due to their desire to protect their partner 39,40 .…”