MCL1 is an anti-apoptotic member of the BCL2 protein family that ensures cell survival by blocking the intrinsic apoptotic cell death pathway. MCL1 is unique in being essential for early embryonic development and the survival of many cell types, including many cancer cells, which are not affected by the loss of the other anti-apoptotic BCL2 family members. Non-apoptotic functions of MCL1 controlling mitochondrial ATP production and dynamics have been proposed to underlie this unique requirement for MCL1. The relative contributions of the anti-apoptotic versus the non-apoptotic functions of MCL1 in normal physiology have not been addressed. Here we replaced the coding sequence for MCL1 with those for the anti-apoptotic proteins BCLXL, BCL2 or A1. We hypothesised that BCLXL, BCL2 and A1 may substitute for MCL1 in the inhibition of apoptosis, but that they will not be able to replace MCL1's non-apoptotic function. Strikingly, Mcl1^BclxL/BclxL and Mcl1^Bcl2/Bcl2 embryos survived to embryonic day 14.5, greatly surpassing the pre-implantation lethality of Mcl1-/- embryos at E3.5. This demonstrates that the non-apoptotic functions of MCL1 are dispensable for early development. However, at later stages of development and life after birth many cell types, particularly ones with high energy demand, were found to require both the anti-apoptotic and the non-apoptotic functions of MCL1. These findings reveal the relative importance of these distinct functions of MCL1 in physiology, providing important information for basic biology and the advancement of MCL1 inhibitors in cancer therapy.