Similar to their sister order Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies), the primarily aquatic larvae of Trichoptera (caddisflies) produce silk, which is used to build a wide variety of underwater architectures, such as cocoons, fixed retreats, and tube-cases. This diverse silk usage allows them to exploit a wide range of aquatic environments. Studies of the long and highly repetitive major silk gene, heavy chain fibroin (h-fibroin), are rare due to difficulties in sequence assembly. Only recently, new long-read sequencing techniques have been used to assemble high-quality, full-length sequences of this gene. Here, we report seven new gene and protein sequences of h-fibroin covering the breadth of the order Trichoptera, including the three major life history strategies characterized by different silk usage (fixed retreat-, cocoon- and tube case-making). When comparing the primary structure of the h-fibroin, we find conserved patterns, but also substantial diversity across groups. The signatures of conservation, such as conservation of N- and C-termini and characteristic repeating structural modules, suggest a common mechanism of silk formation and similar material properties across all three groups. The diversity in the number and order of the repeating modules, as well as the increasing structural complexity of h-fibroin in fixed retreat and tube-case building compared to cocoon-builders, may reflect differences in mechanical properties related to the diversity of silken architectures. This study presents a basis for future research into the role of fibroins in caddisfly silk function as a gauge of the potential of underwater silk in material applications.