Drivers influencing farmer decisions for adopting organic or conventional coffee management practices

Abstract

Colombia is one of the world's most important producers of Arabica coffee (Coffea arabica), whose coffee-growing zone coincides with a biogeographic hotspot of biodiversity. Given that coffee agroecosystems are grown by both organic and conventional schemes of management in Santander, a region which produces coffees with specialist distinctive flavours, this study aims to better understand the factors that influence the adoption of these different schemes of management. A combination of ethnographic techniques and quantitative methods were used to examine the predominant drivers of adoption and revealed farmer perceptions associated with coffee farming, and the complexity of interacting factors, that surround their decision making. The results of qualitative analysis suggests that social identity of coffee growers, the existence of farming spaces (lived, perceived, rationalized), the influence of coffee institutions, attitudes about management practices, and social relations of production, all play an important role in the process of decision making. In quantitative terms, we identified 18 socioeconomic drivers, some with interacting effects that had significant influence on the decision to adopt either organic or conventional practices. In particular, at local scale, important factors were technology availability, the type of landowner, formal education of farmers, the role of institutions, membership of community organizations, farm size, coffee productivity and the number of coffee plots per farm. Likewise, economic drivers, such as crop profitability, determined how farmers are involved in trade and market networks at broad regional, national, and international spatial scales. By adopting a more integrated approach, combining qualitative and quantitative methodologies, we characterized the complexity of factors that influencing adoption of coffee management schemes and show that not only financial factors but also a variety of other social factors drive farmer decision making. Identifying the most influential behavioural drivers provides policy with opportunities to better support farmer livelihoods.

Factors that influence participation of Puerto Rican coffee farmers in conservation programs

“…Our findings echo previous research in Puerto Rico and other coffee growing countries. Financial incentives represent a universal element that farmers and researchers identify as central to conservation programs (Bravo-Monroy, Potts, & Tzanopoulos, 2016;Iverson et al, 2019). Socio-economic characteristics of farmers associate differently with participation.…”

A Real Option Analysis applied to the production of Arabica and Robusta Coffee in Ecuador

“…In comparison, Ecuadorian Robusta coffee was much more expensive (4.87 USD/lb) during the same year. For Arabica coffee, Bravo et al (2016) found a cost C of 1.51USD/ lb in a conventional system for Colombian growers in 2010. For the same year, the difference between Ecuadorian growers and Colombian growers was 1.98 USD/lb.…”

“…Low-price periods affect growers' household income in coffee-producing countries, and encourage them to abandon the crop (ICO, 2002). Even with volatile and uncertain prices, the growers' motivation and decision to remain in the coffee sector are explained through cultural values, inherited coffee (Coffea sp) plantations, tradition and government incentives (Bacon, 2005;Tucker et al, 2010;Borkhataria et al, 2012;Bravo et al, 2016).…”

Energy Efficiency Strategies for Ecological Greenhouses: Experiences from Murcia (Spain)

“…One aspect of the organization's success is the support for improving training amongst workers and farmers. The level of training for farmers affects the extent of development of the agricultural system [82]. As stated by a member of the Organic Cooperative: "From my experience across all these years, I've learned that it is important to specialize in something, it is crucial to have a good team of people, teamwork and personnel are fundamental".…”