Driving Development from Below: The Advantages and Limitations of Vernacular Politics in the BolivianAltiplano

Abstract

Summary Anthropologists studying the Andean community politics have increasingly emphasised the role of pragmatic, informal ‘vernacular’ political strategies in achieving material and political empowerment of the poor. However, while the concept of vernacular politics marks an advancement over binary and often polarised discussions of the role of local communities in development processes, studies have not fully explored the full range of implications of vernacular strategies on development processes. While researchers have demonstrated the substantial agency that local community actors have to influence development processes, the extent to which this influence effectively resists or reinforces the logic of public policy implementation has not been studied. This article explores the techniques used by rural communities in their interactions with public institutions in rural Bolivia. It shows that community organisations' vernacular political strategies have mixed outcomes: on the one hand, they allow the rural poor to assert their own agendas vis‐à‐vis the state so that they can benefit from public spending, while on the other hand, their tactics have the potential to entrench the influence of local power brokers and perpetuate inefficient uses of public funds. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Democratization from below: Civil society in Tajikistan

“…The degree of local civil society empowerment also depends on a “pro‐poor [government] bureaucracy”. (Godfrey‐Wood & Mamani Vargas, 2016) This seems highly unlikely in Tajikistan, although civil society partnerships continue and they can gain power when they include international NGOS.…”