Duality and Social Position: Role expectations of people who combine outsider-ness and insider-ness in organizational change

Abstract

A person’s social position shapes whether and how they can influence organizational change. While prior research establishes people whose social position combines outsider-ness and insider-ness as important change agents, we know little about how they influence change. We analyse a peer coaching initiative in Canadian hospitals to explain how outsider-insiders — in this case, organizational outsiders with professional proximity—advance change. Peer coaches were able to influence change by establishing and enacting a dual outsider-insider role and associated role expectations. We advance theory by showing that role expectations emphasizing duality that are rooted in social position, but created through social interaction, are a key mechanism by which the potential of outsider-insider social positions can be activated and mobilized to influence change. We advance theory on social position generally by highlighting the potential for integrating a symbolic interactionist perspective—focused on role expectations—into Bourdieu’s theory of fields.

Under the Radar: Institutional Drift and Non‐Strategic Institutional Change

“…Relatedly, it is worth exploring the differences between central and peripheral actors, as well as central and peripheral practices. Prior research has acknowledged the impact of these differences in a variety of contexts, primarily focused on the context of more effortful and strategic change initiatives and on the actors, rather than on the practices (Cliff et al, 2006; Nigam et al, in press; Wright and Zammuto, 2013). We would expect that practice deviations are more likely to be unnoticed or ignored, when they are more peripheral – that is less obviously related to the institutional ethos; an example of this occurred when housewives’ business pursuits did not seem to threaten the ‘dutiful housewife’ ethos (Leung et al, 2014).…”

The Role of Moral Anger in Social Change Efforts

“…His initiatives entailed the removal of institutional, economic, or social constraints (Rindova et al, 2009) via “a constant interplay of person, becoming and place, set within the experiential flow of history” (Popp & Holt, 2013, p. 10). Abidi was aware of his interdependence with the government and functioned as a simultaneous insider and outsider with regard to his interactions and work with governmental stakeholders (Nigam, Sackett, & Golden, 2022): someone who was part of a social group and yet simultaneously stood outside it to confront it. After Abidi’s passing, the disability affairs minister acknowledged Abidi’s “guidance” and “key role” in raising awareness and in propelling legislative changes (Ghelot, 2018).…”

The Field of Cultural Production among Religious Community in Higher Education Institution

“…Both the educational and religious institutions are officially and structurally authorized as patrons of the communities or users. Nigam, Sackett, and Golden (2022), stated that an agent's social position has the power to change a structure. This power is rooted in the agent's social position in the field but is also built through social interaction.…”