he stars seemed to be aligned for rindopepimut in 2015. A trio of clinical studies had indicated strongly that this peptide-based vaccine elicited an immune response that could meaningfully delay the progression of glioblastoma multiforme (GBM), the most aggressive form of brain cancer. The vaccine's manufacturer, Celldex Therapeutics of Hampton, New Jersey, lobbied the US Food and Drug Administration for accelerated approval on the basis of phase II data but the agency demurred, preferring to wait for the results of a phase III trial. Unfortunately, that trial was a failure. An interim analysis of the data in early 2016 indicated no improvement in the survival of people with GBM who received the vaccine, and Celldex terminated its development. Patients and clinicians were deeply disappointed, but not necessarily surprised. "Neuro-oncologists tend to be nihilistic in a lot of ways, just because we have seen so many treatments come and go, " says E. Antonio Chiocca, neurosurgeonin-chief at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts. GBM is also the most common form of brain cancer, accounting for around 50% of primary malignancies, and these tumours are almost always fatal. Surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy offer only short-term respite to those affected. The treatment of other tough-totackle cancers, including melanomas, has been Neurosurgeon John Sampson places a treatment-infusing catheter into the brain of a patient with glioblastoma multiforme.