Insulin-secreting β-cells are functionally heterogeneous. Subpopulations of β-cells can control islet function and the regulation of hormone release, such as driving the second (oscillatory) phase of free-calcium ([Ca2+]) following glucose elevation. Whether there exists a subpopulation that drives the first-phase response, critical for effective insulin secretion and disrupted early in diabetes, has not been examined. Here, we examine a ‘first responder’ cell population, defined by the earliest [Ca2+] response during first-phase [Ca2+] elevation. We record [Ca2+] dynamics in intact mouse islets, via β-cell specific expression of the [Ca2+] indicator GCamP6s. We identify multiple β-cell subpopulations based on signatures of their [Ca2+] dynamics and investigate the role of ‘first responder’ cells in islet function by means of 2-photon laser ablation. We further characterize the functional properties of ‘first responder’ cells by NAD(P)H autofluorescence, fluorescent recovery after photobleaching, glibenclamide stimulation, and network analysis. We also investigate which functional characteristics of these cells are critical by a computational model of islet electrophysiology. Based on the dynamics of [Ca2+] responses, first responder cells are distinct from previously identified functional subpopulations. The first-phase response time of β-cells is spatially organized, dependent on the cell’s distance to the first responder cells, and consistent over time up to ~24 h. First responder cells showed characteristics of high membrane excitability and slightly lower than average coupling to their neighbors. When first responder cells were ablated, the first-phase [Ca2+] diminished, compared to ablating a random cell. We also observed a hierarchy of the first-phase response time, where cells that were next earliest to respond often take over the role of the first responder cell upon ablation. In summary, we discover and characterize a distinct first responder β-cell subpopulation, based on [Ca2+] response timing, which is critical for the islet first-phase response to glucose.