“…The conventional view of TDH in the current study supports the findings of Aqeel and Nishat ( 2000 ), Hakro ( 2009 ), and partially with the findings of Siddiqui ( 2010 ) in the case of Pakistan. Besides this, the current study confirms the findings of Salvatore ( 2006 ), Ratha ( 2012 ), Endegnanew et al ( 2013 ), Suresh and Tiwari ( 2014 ), Ravinthirakumaran et al ( 2015 ), and very recent studies of Afonso et al ( 2018 ), Bhat and Sharma ( 2018 ), Akalpler and Panshak ( 2019 ), Baharumshah et al ( 2019 ), Banday and Aneja ( 2019 ), Gaysset et al ( 2019 ), and Mohanty ( 2019 ), Ahmad and Aworinde ( 2020 ), Rehman et al ( 2020 ), Rajakaruna et al ( 2021 ), and Bousnina and Gabsi ( 2022 ). However, the study contradicts the findings of reverse causality running from CAB to fiscal balance by the studies of Rauf and Khan ( 2011 ), Saeed and Khan ( 2012 ), Rehman and Saeed ( 2017 ) in the case of Pakistan and the findings of other studies (like Kim & Kim, 2006 ; Marinheiro, 2008 ; Sobrino, 2013 ; and Nikiforos et al, 2015 ) other than Pakistan.…”