Vegetation fires play an important role in global and regional carbon cycles. Due to climate warming and land use shifts, fire patterns are changing and fire impacts increasing in many of the world's regions. Reducing uncertainties in carbon budgeting calculations from fires is therefore fundamental to advance our current understanding and forecasting capabilities. Here we study 20 chamber burns from the FIREX FireLab experiment, which burnt a representative set of North American wildland fuels, to assess the following: (i) differences in carbon emission estimations between the commonly used "consumed biomass" approach and the "burnt carbon" approach; (ii) pyrogenic carbon (PyC) production rates; and (iii) thermal and chemical recalcitrance of the PyC produced, as proxies of its biogeochemical stability. We find that the "consumed biomass" approach leads to overestimation of carbon emissions by 2-27% (most values between 2% and 10%). This accounting error arises largely from not considering PyC production and, even if relatively small, can therefore have important implications for medium-and long-term carbon budgeting. A large fraction (34-100%) of this PyC was contained in the charred fine residue, a postfire material frequently overlooked in fire carbon research. However, the most recalcitrant PyC was in the form of woody charcoal, with estimated half-lives for most samples exceeding 1,000 years. Combustion efficiency was relatively high in these laboratory burns compared to actual wildland fire conditions, likely leading to lower PyC production rates. We therefore argue that the PyC production values obtained here, and associated overestimation of carbon emissions, should be taken as low-end estimates for wildland fire conditions. Plain Language Summary Wildfires release substantial amounts of carbon into the atmosphere with direct implications for climate change and air quality. However, not all the carbon from the burnt vegetation is emitted; a fraction of it remains on the ground as charcoal (pyrogenic carbon-PyC). PyC is more resistant to degradation than unburnt vegetation, and the carbon it contains can be stored in soils and sediments for long periods of time instead of going back to the atmosphere. Most current carbon emissions estimations do not take PyC production into account and assume that all carbon burnt is emitted into the atmosphere. Here we quantify carbon emissions and PyC production during the FIREX laboratory burns (Missoula Fire Lab, October 2016), where a range of North American vegetation types (e.g., chaparral shrubs, conifer trees) were burnt to study their emissions. We found that the current way of calculating carbon emissions can lead to an overestimation of carbon emissions of between 2% and 27%. We also found that the PyC produced during burning is mostly held not in big woody pieces of charcoal but instead in small charred particles, which are often not accounted for in wildfire research.