Dynamics of the complex food environment underlying dietary intake in low-income groups: a systems map of associations extracted from a systematic umbrella literature review

Abstract

Background Inequalities in obesity pertain in part to differences in dietary intake in different socioeconomic groups. Examining the economic, social, physical and political food environment of low-income groups as a complex adaptive system – i.e. a system of multiple, interconnected factors exerting non-linear influence on an outcome, can enhance the development and assessment of effective policies and interventions by honouring the complexity of lived reality. We aimed to develop and apply novel causal loop diagramming methods in order to construct an evidence-based map of the underlying system of environmental factors that drives dietary intake in low-income groups. Methods A systematic umbrella review was conducted on literature examining determinants of dietary intake and food environments in low-income youths and adults in high/upper-middle income countries. Information on the determinants and associations between determinants was extracted from reviews of quantitative and qualitative studies. Determinants were organised using the Determinants of Nutrition and Eating (DONE) framework. Associations were synthesised into causal loop diagrams that were subsequently used to interpret the dynamics underlying the food environment and dietary intake. The map was reviewed by an expert panel and systems-based analysis identified the system paradigm, structure, feedback loops and goals. Results Findings from forty-three reviews and expert consensus were synthesised in an evidence-based map of the complex adaptive system underlying the food environment influencing dietary intake in low-income groups. The system was interpreted as operating within a supply-and-demand, economic paradigm. Five sub-systems (‘geographical accessibility’, ‘household finances’, ‘household resources’, ‘individual influences’, ‘social and cultural influences’) were presented as causal loop diagrams comprising 60 variables, conveying goals which undermine healthy dietary intake. Conclusions Our findings reveal how poor dietary intake in low-income groups can be presented as an emergent property of a complex adaptive system that sustains a food environment that increases the accessibility, availability, affordability and acceptability of unhealthy foods. In order to reshape system dynamics driving unhealthy food environments, simultaneous, diverse and innovative strategies are needed to facilitate longer-term management of household finances and socially-oriented practices around healthy food production, supply and intake. Ultimately, such strategies must be supported by a system paradigm which prioritises health.

Using Community-Based Prevention Marketing to Generate Demand for Healthy Diets in Jordan

“…The research also highlights that dietary habits and tastes are both deeply personal and profoundly entwined by emotions and social norms. This finding is consistent with other studies which found that social and cultural factors, food beliefs and perceptions influenced dietary behavior among refugees and vulnerable groups [ 28 , 29 , 30 ]. This means that people do not make decisions around food choices and nutrition in isolation or based solely on health outcomes or perceived health benefits.…”

The association between the presence of fast-food outlets and BMI: the role of neighbourhood socio-economic status, healthy food outlets, and dietary factors

“…Moreover, future studies should examine overweight and obesity using systems dynamics approaches. Such approaches model overweight and obesity as part of a complex system [62][63][64], and could thereby move beyond bivariate exposure-outcome associations.…”

Examining the New Zealand school food environment: what needs to change?

“…Household deprivation also plays a significant role in the nutrition behaviours of children (29,31) . Evidence suggests that household food insecurity may lead to the selection of relatively cheap and unhealthy foods, and may also decrease an individual's motivation to eat healthily (11) . In New Zealand, 20% of children aged 0-15 years live in households that report that food 'ran out often' or 'sometimes', making it difficult to consume nutritionally balanced diets (30) .…”

“…Intervention approaches that exclusively target individual-level determinants such as knowledge, beliefs and habits have little or no impact long term (9,10) . However, in combination with environmental-change components these individual approaches have greater effectiveness in improving health behaviours (10,11) .…”