“…As a result, there is lack of consensus among the various groups in the joint formation mechanisms. Current models can be categorized as frictional heating from sliding surfaces solely (Yadav and Doumanidis, 2005; Zhang and Li, 2008; Koellhoffer et al , 2011), frictional heating from sliding surfaces and plastic deformation (Siddiq and Ghassemieh, 2009; Siddiq and Sayed, 2012; Kelly et al , 2013; Kelly et al , 2014), frictional heating and junction growth (Mao, 2016; Ward et al , 2018), dislocation accumulation (Kong et al , 2005; Pal and Stucker, 2013), energy input from friction (Yang et al , 2010; Yi et al , 2017), plastic deformation heating (Sriraman et al , 2011) and ultrasonic energy input and microstructure storage (Hehr et al , 2016; Hehr and Dapino, 2017). Some of the modeling efforts use acoustic softening (Siddiq and Ghassemieh, 2009; Siddiq and Sayed, 2012; Kelly et al , 2013; Kelly et al , 2014), which is contested itself as a mechanism in ultrasonic deformation processes versus stress superposition (Graff, 2015).…”