Dynamometer-based measure of spasticity confirms limited association between plantarflexor spasticity and walking function in persons with multiple sclerosis

Abstract

The literature shows inconsistent evidence regarding the association between clinically assessed plantarflexor (PF) spasticity and walking function in ambulatory persons with multiple sclerosis (pwMS). The use of a dynamometer-based spasticity measure (DSM) may help to clarify this association. Our cohort included 42 pwMS (27 female, 15 male; age: 42.9 +/− 10.2 yr) with mild clinical disability (Expanded Disability Status Scale score: 3.6 +/− 1.6). PF spasticity was assessed using a clinical measure, the modified Ashworth Scale (MAS), and an instrumented measure, the DSM. Walking function was assessed by the timed 25-foot walk test (T25FWT), the 6-minute walk test (6MWT), and the 12-item Multiple Sclerosis Walking Scale (MSWS-12). Spearman rho correlations were used to evaluate relationships between spasticity measures, measures of walking speed and endurance, and self-perceived limitations in walking. The correlation was small between PF spasticity and the T25FWT (PF maximum [Max] MAS rho = 0.27, PF Max DSM rho = 0.26), the 6MWT (PF Max MAS rho = −0.20, PF Max DSM rho = −0.21), and the MSWS-12 (PF Max MAS rho = 0.11, PF Max DSM rho = 0.26). Our results are similar to reports in other neurologic clinical populations, wherein spasticity has a limited association with walking dysfunction.

Assessment and Measurement of Spasticity in MS: State of the Evidence

“…A number of other instrumented versions of clinical spasticity tests have been developed, but none of these has been evaluated in PwMS and none has sufficient validation to clearly be recommended in other conditions [26]. In addition, some authors have used isokinetic dynamometers and EMG to assess muscle activation during stretching in PwMS, but this approach requires large isokinetic dynamometer equipment rarely available at this time [27, 28].…”