Early Childhood Education Teacher Well-Being: Performativity as a Means of Coping

Abstract

Detrimental circumstances (e.g., poverty, homelessness) may affect parents, parenting, and children. These circumstances may lead to children being labeled “at risk” for school failure. To ameliorate this risk, more school and school earlier (e.g., Head Start) is offered. To improve child outcomes, Head Start teachers are expected to bolster children?s academic readiness in a manner that is beneficially warm, circulating warmth in their classrooms to sustain positive teacher-child relationships and the positive climate of the classroom. The Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS; Pianta et al., 2008) is one tool by which these domains of warmth are assessed. There are, however, significant personal and professional stressors with which Head Start teachers contend which the CLASS (Pianta et al., 2008) does not consider in its scoring methods. Uplifting the voices of six Head Start teachers, the present study implemented individual and focus group interviews during the summer and fall months of 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, asking (a) What were the stories, histories, and lived experiences of these Head Start teachers with regard to stress and warmth in a time of crisis? and (b) How did these teachers understand and approach the CLASS (Pianta et al., 2008) and its measures of their warmth? Data demonstrated Head Start teachers engaged in a type of performativity to 1) mask their stress, potentially worsening their levels of stress in order to maintain warmth for their students’ sake, and 2) outwit the prescribed CLASS (Pianta et al., 2008) observations. Implications and insights are discussed. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10643-022-01387-2.

Early Childhood Education Teacher Workforce: Stress in Relation to Identity and Choices

“…Indicative of that which should not be incorporated into a teacher’s identity with passive acceptance, stress may be normalized, inculcated in the moment-to-moment decisions and actions taking shape in a classroom, thereafter, potentially affecting teachers, children, and families. It may also be considered that perhaps the means by which stress affects the formation of the micro-identity serves to (1) tamp down other, more estimable teacher identities (e.g., warmth, acceptance), forcing teachers to hide other parts of their identity (e.g., vulnerability, an authentic self), and/or thereafter (2) amplify performativity, masking stress, in order to recalibrate the classroom environment in favor of warmth and nurturance (Wiltshire, 2022 ).…”

The Use of Qualitative Case Studies of Graduate School Students: A Quantitative Analysis of their Depression Scale

“…Depression in young people can be exacerbated by peer pressure, scholastic stress, and the emergence of independence. In addition, issues with relationships, job decisions, and identity formation may confront young adults (Wiltshire, 2023). When people reach middle age, they may suffer from depression as a result of life upheavals including changing careers, the empty nest syndrome (when kids move out), and health issues.…”