Early Detection of Tuberculosis Outbreaks among the San Francisco Homeless: Trade-Offs Between Spatial Resolution and Temporal Scale

Abstract

BackgroundSan Francisco has the highest rate of tuberculosis (TB) in the U.S. with recurrent outbreaks among the homeless and marginally housed. It has been shown for syndromic data that when exact geographic coordinates of individual patients are used as the spatial base for outbreak detection, higher detection rates and accuracy are achieved compared to when data are aggregated into administrative regions such as zip codes and census tracts. We examine the effect of varying the spatial resolution in the TB data within the San Francisco homeless population on detection sensitivity, timeliness, and the amount of historical data needed to achieve better performance measures.Methods and FindingsWe apply a variation of space-time permutation scan statistic to the TB data in which a patient's location is either represented by its exact coordinates or by the centroid of its census tract. We show that the detection sensitivity and timeliness of the method generally improve when exact locations are used to identify real TB outbreaks. When outbreaks are simulated, while the detection timeliness is consistently improved when exact coordinates are used, the detection sensitivity varies depending on the size of the spatial scanning window and the number of tracts in which cases are simulated. Finally, we show that when exact locations are used, smaller amount of historical data is required for training the model.ConclusionSystematic characterization of the spatio-temporal distribution of TB cases can widely benefit real time surveillance and guide public health investigations of TB outbreaks as to what level of spatial resolution results in improved detection sensitivity and timeliness. Trading higher spatial resolution for better performance is ultimately a tradeoff between maintaining patient confidentiality and improving public health when sharing data. Understanding such tradeoffs is critical to managing the complex interplay between public policy and public health. This study is a step forward in this direction.

Detecting Spatial-Temporal Clusters of HFMD from 2007 to 2011 in Shandong Province, China

“…The method had been widely used to detect clusters of infectious disease and may serve as a useful adjunct to disease surveillance, particularly in areas of limited resources, e.g., malaria [34], dengue [35], Japanese encephalitis [36], tuberculosis [37] and HFMD [32], etc. However, the Scan statistics are based on the assumption of circular spatial scanning windows and space-time cylinders to detect clusters, while the actual shapes of clusters were not all like that.…”

Assessing spatiotemporal patterns of multidrug-resistant and drug-sensitive tuberculosis in a South American setting

“…census tract or ZIP code) since information on population density is often available only at these gross administrative levels. However, such aggregated analyses will result in a lower sensitivity for detecting TB outbreaks than analyses using individual-level data [22, 23]. Since our approach used comparisons of MDR and non-MDR cases arising from the same base population, our analysis is not compromised by non-uniform population density and thus we were able to utilize the highest possible level of resolution (i.e.…”

The characteristics of spatial-temporal distribution and cluster of tuberculosis in Yunnan Province, China, 2005-2018.

“…Scan statistics were widely applied in study topic related to TB [39][40][41][42][43], whereas, data aggregated into large scales of administrative regions may ignore the disease variation in small size of population, information lose lead to inaccurate and insensitive conclusion [44], these national-level researches could not preciously detect localized cluster on the resolution of province or prefecture [9,10,45]. Meanwhile, due to the stochastic scan statistics sensitive to parameters, the analytical results on high-resolution scan of county-level may not stable.…”