Early-Holocene temperature variability inferred from chironomid assemblages at Hawes Water, northwest England

Abstract

This paper presents the first high-resolution chironomid-inferred mean July air temperature (C-IT) reconstruction for the early Holocene from England. The reconstruction is based on a core recovered from a terrestrialised carbonate bench at Hawes Water, a small hard-water lake in northwest England. The record shows that temperatures rose rapidly after the Younger Dryas with temperatures reaching 14.0°C at the beginning of the Holocene. Over millennial timescales, the temperature record points to a slight rise in temperatures towards the top of the sequence at around 8000 years before the year 2000 (b2k). The trend is punctuated by a series of cool oscillations (at 11 200, 11 400, 10 700, 10 400, 9300 and 8300 b2k) and by a short period (11 300 to 10 250 b2k) when temperatures were considerably warmer (up to 14.9°C). The five cool oscillations coincide with temperature reversals found elsewhere in the North Atlantic region and in the Greenland ice core records. These cool events correlate well with both meltwater fluxes from the Laurentide and Scandinavian ice sheets and periods of low solar activity. Two of these oscillations (at 9300 and 8300 b2k) vary significantly from the early-Holocene mean. C-IT shift rapidly during both these events and temperatures fall ~1.6°C below the early-Holocene mean trend for ~ 50-60 years. The results presented here provide an insight into the instability of the early-Holocene climate in the British Isles and demonstrate the sensitivity of chironomids to rapid climatic events during the early Holocene. KeywordsBritish Isles, chironomid, early Holocene, Hawes Water, temperature reconstruction, 8.2 ka event, 9.3 ka event The Holocene 20(6) 943-954

Climatic influence upon early to mid-Holocene fire regimes within temperate woodlands: a multi-proxy reconstruction from the New Forest, southern England

“…This agrees with other palaeoclimate records from the UK which show a cool, dry climatic anomaly in the region (e.g. Rousseau et al ., ; Lang et al ., ), and is clearly recorded in the GISP2 oxygen isotope record (Alley et al ., ). The broad agreement of the Cranes Moor BSW data with other regional climatic proxies implies that the mire is climatically sensitive through this period.…”

Lateglacial and early Holocene climates of the Atlantic margins of Europe: Stable isotope, mollusc and pollen records from Orkney, Scotland

“…Both events have been previously inferred from British deposits (e.g. Edwards et al, 2007;Marshall et al, 2007;Lang et al, 2010a;Daley et al, 2011), though relatively infrequently for the 9.3 ka event. We feel it important to stress the uncertainty associated with the isotopic perturbations in the Holocene section of the profile.…”

“…This applies equally, of course, to single proxy studies (e.g. chironomids e Lang et al, 2010a;Brooks et al, 2012;Brooks and Langdon, 2014). In spite of an abundance of publications globally, relatively few palaeoisotope studies have been carried out in Britain (e.g.…”

A wild boar dominated ungulate assemblage from an early Holocene natural pit fall trap: Cave shaft sediments in northwest England associated with the 9.3 ka BP cold event

“…Cool oscillations around 11.4,11.2,10.7,10.4,9.3 and 8.2 ka BP have been recorded by Lang et al (2010) from chironomid assemblages in carbonate sediment at Hawes Water, 19 km west of the Cupcake (Figure 1).…”