ECB's unconventional monetary policy and spillover effects between sovereign and bank credit risk

Abstract

PurposeThe paper examines the impact of the deteriorating fiscal conditions of Eurozone countries on spillover effects on bank credit margins. It is investigated whether these effects have been reduced after European Central Bank’s (ECB) signaling of pursuing an expansionary, unconventional, monetary policy to address the debt crisis in Eurozone.Design/methodology/approachA general econometric panel model is applied to investigate spillover effects between Eurozone countries and bank credit margins. In total, three periods are examined: the period before the peak of the global financial crisis and the beginning of the Irish banking crisis, the period during the debt and bank crisis in Eurozone and the period after ECB's signaling of extremely aggressive monetary easing.FindingsAccording to empirical results, before the peak of the global financial crisis there was no substantial credit risk transfer from Eurozone sovereigns to banks. During the period of debt and bank crisis in Eurozone, the deterioration of the fiscal situation of Eurozone countries had a significant impact on bank Credit Default Swap (CDS) spreads. After ECB's signaling of extremely aggressive monetary easing, it does not seem to be any significant relationship between Eurozone sovereigns and bank CDS spreads. These findings reinforce the assessment that ECB's measures were effective, achieving the key objective of normalizing economic conditions and ensuring financial stability in Eurozone.Research limitations/implicationsA question is whether effects can change when the corresponding contraction will lead to a reinstatement of “normal” conditions. Would there be a reversal of risk premium trends in bond markets? Although the answer from casual observations seems to be negative, it is a valid research question to be examined. An interesting issue concerning the unconventional monetary policy measures implemented by ECB concerns the issues of moral hazard that they incorporate, something that could not be addressed. Another research perspective could be the use of the beta coefficient to measure the systematic and unsystematic risk of banking sector shares.Practical implicationsThe results have strong implications for ECB and European banking regulation. Regulators should mainly pay more attention to the amount and concentration of sovereign debt held by banks. Eurozone financial system could be less vulnerable to the sovereign credit risk. It raised the critical question of whether a more strict regulation is needed. Regulators should not intervene if not necessary, but they must prevent the transmission of crises between markets. This will likely bring trust to the developed countries' sovereign debt and the portfolios of the financial institutions, which hold most of this debt will be considered safe as well.Social implicationsThe conclusions provide a safe counterweight in various respects. First, the negative effects and the need to rapidly cease or limit such policies. Second, the financial stability aimed by ECB. Such policies contain the possibility of a subsequent moral hazard related to Member State and bank behavior. However, these contingencies need to be assessed with the benefits resulting from the restoration of financial markets and the disconnection between banking and sovereign credit risk. This leads Eurozone's financial system to become less vulnerable to the sovereign credit risk and therefore more safe, helping to restore confidence in the real economy.Originality/valueContribution in terms of methodology and conclusions. It offers important conclusions regarding the limitations of yields and volatility of CDS spreads. It examines the spillover effects of the fiscal situation of Eurozone countries on banking institutions by extending the existing methodology and introducing new questions focusing on the reaction of CDS market to the ECB monetary policy, the reduction of risk premiums at sovereign and banking level and the gradual reduction of interdependence between them.

The Effect of ECB Unconventional Monetary Policy on Firms’ Performance during the Global Financial Crisis

“…A more representative picture of the prevailed situation during the financial crisis period in the EU can be revealed by the study of Katsampoxakis (2021), who examined the impact of fiscal conditions on banks' credit margins in Eurozone countries and the contribution of the ECB's unconventional monetary policy in Eurozone crisis. The period under consideration consisted of three subperiods.…”

Can ESG Stocks Be a Safe Haven during Global Crises? Evidence from the COVID-19 Pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine War with Time-Frequency Wavelet Analysis

“…Their empirical analysis included unit root tests, Granger causality, and ARCH family models to test for linkages between the two types of indices and error correction models and Johansen cointegration tests to find contagion of volatility. This research approach is relevant to many other interesting studies being conducted (Kenourgios and Dimitriou 2015;Gong et al 2019;Zhang et al 2020;Katsampoxakis 2021).…”

Accountant Perceptions and Attitudes Towards the Social Accounting Practices in Bangladesh

“…Historical findings suggest that financial indicators influence the manufacturing industry, automotive sector and numerous small and medium sized firms largely; firm age, market concentration and economic growth (GDP) have substantial impact on organizational effectiveness (Pervan et al, 2019;Yadav et al, 2022). Katsampoxakis (2021) gave voice to banks' strict regulation for improving the financial system whereas another study pointed out determinants i.e. firm size, profit instability do not affect the firm profitability and using firm size as dummy variable it maintained a positive association (Katsampoxakis et al, 2015;Eriotis et al, 2007).…”