Ecological Public Health and Participatory Planning and Assessment Dilemmas: The Case of Water Resources Management

Abstract

Water is a key driver for socio-economic development, livelihoods and ecosystem integrity. This is reflected in the emergence of unified paradigms such as Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM) and the weight accorded to it in the Sustainable Development Goals agenda. This paper interrogated the effectiveness of existing participatory planning and assessment models adapted from IWRM model on water quality and public health at community level. The analysis was built around public health ecology perspective and drew useful lessons from critique of basin wide integrated Modeling approaches and existing community participatory models envisaged under Water Users Associations (WUA) in South Africa. We extended the use of political ecology lenses to ecological public health through use of communication for development approaches, to argue that public health risk reduction and resilience building in community water projects require the use of innovative analytical and conceptual lenses that unbundle cognitive biases and failures, as well as, integrate and transform individual and collective agency. The study concludes that the inherent “passive participation” adapted from IWRM model fail to adequately address water quality and public health dimensions in its pillars. Since water quality has direct bearing on disaster risks in public health, building a coherent mitigatory vision requires the adoption of active participatory assessment and planning models that incorporate livelihoods, agency, social learning dynamics and resilience through recognition of communication for development approaches in community empowerment.

‘Water is life’: developing community participation for clean water in rural South Africa

“…As well as advancing nation-building, the government embraced the international Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM) paradigm 21. Over time, IWRM came to be seen as overly complex and technocratic, however, limiting the state’s role, with insufficient attention to context, integration and overlooking poverty alleviation 22. This was followed by calls for a renewed focus on context in policy, strategic intervention and resource mobilisation with community participation as a unifying concept 23 24.…”

Perception of Environmental Spillovers across Scale in Climate Change Adaptation Planning: The Case of Small-Scale Farmers’ Irrigation Strategies, Kenya

“…Perception of risk, habit, social status, and age as individual attributes are thus critical in collective action decision-making [20]. At community level analytical and conceptual lenses that unbundle cognitive biases and failures, as well as, integrate and transform individual and collective agency are critical in risk reduction and resilience building [69]. Theoretical and empirical multiplicity lenses improve analytical rigour, address conceptual and knowledge gaps, as well as, solve complex problems and contextual dilemmas while encouraging synergies [25,59].…”

Public Health Emergency and Crisis Management: Case Study of SARS-CoV-2 Outbreak

“…South Korea was considered the second most affected nation until March 2020; however, as of late May 2020, the South Korean public health system is deemed a model of virus containment. South Korea's public health authorities never implemented a "true" lockdown [1][2][3]. Most businesses stayed open, and borders have not been completely closed down to prevent overseas travel.…”