Economic Crisis and Attitudes Towards Democracy: How Ideology Moderates Reactions to Economic Downturns

Abstract

This paper studies the extent to which economic crises bust different reactions depending on individual ideological identity. Our argument is that individual left-right identification shapes how citizens evaluate the functioning of democracy, and consequently, it moderates the impact of economic crises on democratic discontent. We argue that left-wing individuals’ views on democratic performance would be more heavily affected by economic results and strongly shaped by the (in)capacity of a democracy to represent its citizens in its reaction to the economic crisis. After testing our argument with data from the ESS, we provide evidence from a survey experiment conducted in Spain. Both analyses show that economic crises are relevant in explaining democratic dissatisfaction, but the strength of their impact depends on ideological identities. Economic results have a stronger effect on the satisfaction with democracy of left-wing individuals by negatively affecting their perception of the functioning of democratic representation.

Perceptions of Inequality and Political Participation: The Moderating Role of Ideology

“…We here focus on left-right ideology since it has a straightforward connection to perceptions of inequality, and previous studies have shown that the impact of central political attitudes may differ substantially depending on ideology (Christensen and von Schoultz, 2019). Previous studies have also shown that ideology may moderate how inequality affects political behaviour (Armingeon and Weisstanner, 2021;Jurado and Navarrete, 2021). The left-right ideological dimension is usually seen as the ideological dimension structuring most political conflicts (Downs, 1957), which in Europe has divided politics into the liberal-conservative right and the social-democratic or socialist left.…”

The Ideological Drivers Behind the Support for the Use of Direct Democracy among Voters and Parties of Benelux Countries

“…Although the literature questioning the link between ideological preferences and political participation of all kinds is well developed, while the one connecting ideology and vote choice is abundant, the impact on democratic preferences remains much less substantial (Ceka and Magalhães 2016;Jurado and Navarrete 2021). That is the reason why, inspired by the above-mentioned argument of an affinity between citizens' participation and left-wing values, some scholars have brought in the idea that the support for the enlargement of participatory opportunities and the use of policy instruments that would give a greater role to citizens in decision-making might be driven by where people stand on the left/right cleavage.…”

The Impact of the 2019 Lebanese Multidimensional Crisis on Young Adults’ Political Attitudes and Behavior. (c2022)

“…People with varying ideological backgrounds have differing experiences during an economic crisis. Using survey data from 2002 to 2014 in Spain, Jurado and Navarrete (2021) concluded that the impact of economic crises greatly depends on the citizen's ideological identity.…”