Economic valuation of Baltic marine ecosystem services: blind spots and limited consistency

Abstract

Economic valuation of marine ecosystem services in the Baltic Sea region has gained importance, as policy-makers are recognizing their decline and focusing on achieving good environmental status there in terms of, for example, reduced eutrophication. Parallel with this development, several initiatives have been launched, leading to a large number of economic valuation studies. However, current research indicates that neither a common approach to classifying ecosystem services nor a widely accepted methodological framework for assessing their economic value exist yet. This paper seeks to shed light on the current state of the economic valuation of ecosystem services provided by the Baltic Sea through reviewing all currently available empirical studies on the topic. The results indicate that only a few ecosystem services, including recreation and reduction of eutrophication, have been extensively monetarily valued, and still lack cross-study methodological consistency, while many other marine ecosystem services have rarely or never been valued with economic methods. The paper concludes that existing economic valuation studies provide only limited practical guidance for policy-makers intending to improve the environmental status of the Baltic Sea. There is a need for more widely shared agreement on the systematic nature of marine and coastal ecosystem services and especially on a coherent methodological framework for assessing their economic value.

Understanding the distribution of economic benefits from improving coastal and marine ecosystems

“…We try to make this drawback less 15 severe by making the software codes and the estimation package available online. We believe it can 16 provide an alternative to the currently used approaches. 17 18…”

Advancing Citizen Science for Coastal and Ocean Research

“…Studies such as those by Bertram et al (2014) have attempted a cost-benefit analysis of environmental protective measures in the marine context, and there is now a growing literature on economic valuation of ecosystem services (e.g. see Sagebiel et al 2016) including the value members of the public put on marine resources and services (e.g. Brouwer et al 2016).…”

What evidence exists for the impact of Baltic Sea ecosystems on human health and well-being? A systematic map protocol

“…The Baltic Sea ecosystems supply many unique benefits to society [2,16,34]. The benefits from the sea contribute to the health and well-being of individuals and communities through provisioning services such as food, medicines, fertilisers; regulatory services such as the regulation of harmful substances and clean water; and finally cultural services such as the traditional activities like ice-sea fishing or the spiritual/religious beliefs associated with the Baltic Sea maritime and coastal ecosystems.…”