“…Furthermore, the TCF can detect a U-shaped average cost curve if one exists in the data, which is the restrictive property of production function like the Cobb-Douglas (Brown and O'Connor, 1995). The TCF has been used in many studies on economies of scale in broad type of industries, such as in credit union (Brown and O'Connor, 1995), cooperative (Kebede and Schreiner, 1996;Liu and Bailey, 2012), banking (Deelchand and Padgett, 2009;Sahoo and Gstach, 2011;Fu and Sio, 2011), payment processing (Beijnen and Bolt, 2009), electricity (Tuthill, 2008), fifteen major sectors of the economy (Haouas and Heshmati, 2013), water utilities (Horn and Saito, 2011), airport (Martin and Voltes-Dorta, 2008), and tourism (Shi and Smyth, 2012) Following Liu and Bailey (2012), this study used producer approach in which cooperatives were treated as firms that provide services to consumers. With this approach, only labor and physical capital were considered as inputs necessary to conduct transactions (Margono et al, 2010;Deelchand and Padgett, 2009).…”