Economies of scope: context of agriculture, small family farmers and sustainability

Abstract

What does this article offers? It raises questions on the assumptions of efficiency in agriculture, traces the history of the logic of scale replacing logic of scope, analyses its impact on sustainability and offers a framework to discern technical contradictions of efficiency across different sectors and find a balance for sustainability. It delves with a few basic questions: First, what is the assumption for efficiency in agriculture and food production? Second, how efficiency criterion of dominant players in one leading sector decimates the efficiency wisdom of another sector? Tracing the evolution of theory and practice of 'economies of scale' during the last three centuries of industrial revolution, the article shows the irony of adopting economies of scale time and again only to face greater economic recession, market failures, climate changes, food crisis and growing un-sustainability of our ecosystem. Through empirical evidences from small family farmers and farmer producer organizations from across India and based on the findings of eight years of action research on designing sustainable producer organization, the article highlights that 'economies of scope' in agriculture is not only more efficient for nutritious food production and climate resilience but also for sustainability of agricultural ecosystems and of overall socio-economic-environment.

On the challenges of making a sustainable kitchen: experimenting with sustainable food principles for restaurants

“…Small family farmers might have lower economics of scale, but they have higher economies of scope, implying that they tend to focus more on details that lead to high-quality produce. Besides, small family farmers tend to have more diverse and seasonal production systems (Principle 1) (Nayak, 2018). Favouring small production also keeps more income in the local economy, and it allows family farmers to capture a higher share of profits that are distributed across the value chain, thus it is an ethical decision to support them (Hebinck, Schneider, & van der Ploeg, 2014).…”

Social capital and performance of farmers' groups in producer organizations in India: examining the mediating role of self-efficacy

“…The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at: https://www.emerald.com/insight/2044-0839.htm plethora of existing problems of small and marginal farmers (Nayak, 2018), and found to be a successful initiative to integrate them into modern supply chain for better performance (Bikkina et al, 2018). Several studies also confirm that collective action increases efficiency, productivity and performance of farmers (Uphoff and Wijayaratna, 2000;Grootaert and Bastelaer, 2002;Waddington et al, 2014).…”

“…In India, FPOs are being mobilized to build their own enterprises which in turn offer farmers to participate effectively in the field production and market activities (Krishna et al. , 2018), these collectives have started business under hybrid model of company and cooperative to solve plethora of existing problems of small and marginal farmers (Nayak, 2018), and found to be a successful initiative to integrate them into modern supply chain for better performance (Bikkina et al. , 2018).…”