Ecosystem Services as a Promising Paradigm to Protect Environmental Rights of Indigenous Peoples in Latin America: the Constitutional Court Landmark Decision to Protect Arroyo Bruno in Colombia

Abstract

In the last years, the interest in ecosystem services (ESs) as a decision-making tool for environmental policy has been growing. The ES paradigm has also impacted the judicial system and in some countries the common law tradition. Experiences and lessons learned from the ES litigation have been already documented. In the initial analysis, this article aims to identify key trends in ESs case law in Latin America—a leading region in environmental constitutionalism—by exploring the judicial decisions issued by high courts and subnational environmental courts that mention or incorporate the ES term. In the second level of analysis, we focused on the Colombian Constitutional Court landmark decision; the Arroyo Bruno judgment aimed to protect the rights to water, food security, and health of the Wayuú indigenous people. We argue this is a groundbreaking ruling in Latin America, given that for the first time, a Court uses the ES-based approach to protect the environmental rights of ethnic communities, incorporating ES concepts to the constitutional law sphere and integrating into the same conversation, interdisciplinary and intercultural knowledge.

Polycentric and resilient perspectives for governing the commons: Strategic and law and economics insights for sustainable development

“…In both cases, the right to water has been gaining a renewed consensus, although more stringent actions to protect water and further commons still need to be undertaken (Zanotelli 2010 ; Carrozza and Fantini 2016 ; Wolkmer and Melo, 2012 , 2020 ). This is the case for local indigenous communities and vulnerable socioeconomic groups, who would benefit from engaging with standards and parameters such as ecosystem services for decision-making (Gómez-Betancur and Torres 2021 ). In the Italian case, more practical pieces of evidence emerged—above all, the Italian public referendum against the privatization of water governance in 2011, the implementation of commons department within Naples municipality, and the municipalization of new ecological and participatory conversion of the Neapolitan local water utility.…”

Analisis Perubahan Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi dalam Konteks Pemilu 2024 Melalui Tinjauan Hukum Tata Negara

“…Keempat, ada kelompok masyarakat yang mungkin tidak terlalu peduli atau tidak memiliki pengetahuan yang mendalam tentang perubahan putusan MK. Mereka mungkin tidak memiliki minat yang tinggi dalam isu-isu hukum atau politik yang terkait dengan pemilihan (Gómez-Betancur, 2022). Tanggapan mereka terhadap perubahan putusan MK mungkin lebih didasarkan pada persepsi umum tentang stabilitas politik dan kepercayaan mereka terhadap lembaga peradilan.…”

Prawa przyrody w ochronie środowiska i wzmacnianiu bezpieczeństwa ekologicznego

“…Zrównoważone korzystanie z zasobów naturalnych warunkuje dobrobyt człowieka, kompleksową ochronę obszarów przyrodniczych z uwzględnieniem kontekstu środowiskowego, ekologii społecznej i etnoekologii. Prawa przyrody rozszerzają konstytucjonalizm na domenę środowiskową 50 . Jak zaznaczyła M.M.…”