atrial fibrillation, catheter ablation, phrenic nerve injury, superior vena cava
Editorial CommentPhrenic nerve injury (PNI) is a major complication of cardiac ablation procedures leading to paralysis of the diaphragm. Anectodal reports on PNI after ablation of left-sided accessory pathways, right-sided atrial tachycardias, and epicardial ablation of ventricular tachycardias exist, but it is more common in atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation. PNI is rare after isolation of the right-sided (mostly superior) pulmonary vein (PV) (up to 0.48%) 1 or isolation of the superior vena cava (SVC) (2.1%) 2 using radiofrequency energy. In contrast, it has been documented in up to 20% of PV isolation procedures in highly experienced centers using the cryoballoon generation 1 and 2, making this the most common complication among all AF ablation technologies. 3,4 The high incidence of PNI during cryo-PV isolation is related to the specifications of the ablation balloon and the proximity of the PN to the right superior PV. Although approximately 80% of PNI resolve this, it may take as long as 15 months and symptoms may be disabling and worse than AF-related impairment.
2,5Transient PNI occurs earlier (at lower temperatures during heating and potentially higher temperatures during cooling) than persistent PNI enabling use of prophylactic sensitive screening with CMAP monitoring during ablation at critical sites with the potential for prompt restitution of normal diaphragm motility. Therefore, the field of prevention has prompted scientific evaluations in recent years.Whereas careful observation of the diaphragm motion on fluoroscopy during isolation of the right superior PV during spontaneous breathing or pacing of the right-sided PN may detect relevant paralysis early, detection of impaired diaphragm contraction may become identified only when using diaphragm electromyography as a surrogate parameter of PN function. First described in 1967, recordings of compound motor action potentials (CMAP) of the diaphragm were later regularly used to gather information on PN function in patients with neuromuscular diseases.9 Monitoring CMAP as a surrogate for right PN function during AF ablation was initially applied in 2011 10 and since then has gained wide acceptance as surveillance of PNI during cryo-PV isolation.
11CMAP can easily be obtained using two additional surface ECG electrodes positioned approximately 5 cm above the xiphoid and 16 cm along the right costal margin as optimal positions.12 Ideal sites of recording are not confined to these sites but especially a recording site cm away from the 16 cm point along the costal margin may be used, making this technology easy to use and reduce potential recording errors. During pacing of the right PN superior to the attempted ablation area diaphragm, CMAPs are recorded via these two patch-electrodes and displayed on a regular electrophysiology recording system. During ablation the amplitude of the CMAP is observed and a decrease of CMAP is used as an indicator for impeding PNI. Animal studi...