Glutathione reductase-like metalloid reductase (GRLMR) is an enzyme that reduces selenodiglutathione (GS-Se-SG), forming zerovalent Se nanoparticles (SeNPs). Error-prone polymerase chain reaction was used to create a library of ∼10,000 GRLMR variants. The library was expressed in BL21Escherichia coli in liquid culture with 50 mM of SeO 3 2− present, under the hypothesis that the enzyme variants with improved GS-Se-SG reduction kinetics would emerge. The selection resulted in a GRLMR variant with two mutations. One of the mutations (D−E) lacks an obvious functional role, whereas the other mutation is L− H within 5 Å of the enzyme active site. This mutation places a second H residue within 5 Å of an active site dicysteine. This GRLMR variant was characterized for NADPH-dependent reduction of GS-Se-SG, GSSG, SeO 3 2− , SeO 4 2− , GS-Te-SG, and TeO 3 2− . The evolved enzyme demonstrated enhanced reduction of SeO 3 2− and gained the ability to reduce SeO 4 2−. This variant is named selenium reductase (SeR) because of its emergent broad activity for a wide variety of Se substrates, whereas the parent enzyme was specific for GS-Se-SG. This study overall suggests that new biosynthetic routes are possible for inorganic nanomaterials using laboratory-directed evolution methods.