Effect of a surgical observership on the perceptions and career choices of preclinical medical students: a mixed-methods study

Abstract

Background: Medical students are increasingly choosing nonsurgical specialties; observership programs can address factors influencing them toward surgical careers by allowing preclerkship exposure and mentorship, and correcting misconceptions. The aims of this study were to assess the influence of a peer-led observership program at the Université de Montréal on the career choices of preclinical medical students and to determine the factors associated with a positive observership experience. Methods: We used a quasi-experimental convergent mixed-methods questionnaire design. From Nov. 19 to Dec. 31, 2018, and Mar. 1 to Apr. 4, 2019, all medical students participating in the observership program were eligible for the study; there were no ineligibility criteria. Using a prospective purposive sampling method, we recruited students via the email sent to confirm their observership. In the week after their observership, we invited the students by email to complete a postintervention survey. We used nonparametric tests to evaluate the impact of the observership on participants’ career choices and an inductive data-driven thematic analysis to analyze their responses. Results: Of the 204 students who participated, 157 provided consent, of whom 85 (54.1%) completed questionnaires both before and after the observership. The majority of participants were interested in a surgical specialty before (72 [85%]) and after (68 [84%]) the observership. There was no significant change in the students’ choices of surgical specialties after the observership. However, most (68 [81%]) reported being more interested in a surgical career as a result of the observership, which allowed them to see that the type of practice they considered was congruent with a surgical career. Their perceptions of the field of surgery became positive, particularly regarding its pace and atmosphere and the humanistic patient–doctor relationship it required. The experience was influenced by surgeons’ and teams’ attitudes toward students, knowledge-sharing and quality of exposure. Participants mentioned that their willingness to participate was in part responsible for the success of their experience. Conclusion: This observership program allowed an early, positive introduction of students to surgery while challenging stereotypes. It provided a better understanding of surgery, enabling participants to consider this field and potentially influencing their residency application.

The Future Career Choices of Pre-Registered House Officers and House Surgeons: a Multicenter Study

“…Hamid .S et al Contrary, in the US, a recent study states that more than 80% of students chose surgery as a future choice during observer ship, most of whom are females. 14,15 In the present study, 47% of individuals planned to complete residency abroad, while a recent study done in Peshawar reported that 39% of nal-year students would like to complete residency abroad. 16 Another study in Peshawar reported that 53% of individuals set caveats for postgraduation abroad.…”