We perform spatially resolved measurements of temperature, gaseous species up to three-ring Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), and soot in atmospheric pressure counterflow diffusion flames. First, we characterize fully a baseline ethylene flame and then a tolueneseeded flame in which an aliquot of ethylene in the feed stream is replaced with 3500 ppm of prevaporized toluene. The goal is twofold: to investigate the impact of a common reference fuel component of surrogates of transportation fuels and bypass the main bottleneck to soot formation from aliphatic fuels, that is, the formation of the first aromatic ring. The composition of the fuel and oxidizer streams are adjusted to maintain a constant stoichiometric mixture fraction and global strain rate, thereby ensuring invariance of the temperature−time history in the comparison between the two flames and decoupling the chemical effects of the fuel substitution from other factors. Major combustion products and critical radicals are fixed by the baseline flame, and profiles of critical C2−C5 species precursors to aromatic formation are invariant in both flames. On the other hand, doping with toluene boosts the aromatic content and soot volume fraction, increasing the mole fraction of benzenoid structures and soot volume fraction by a factor of 2 or 3, relative to the baseline ethylene flame. This finding is consistent with the expectation that the formation of the first aromatic ring is no longer a bottleneck to soot formation in the doped flame. In addition, toluene bypasses completely benzene formation, opening a radical recombination pathway to soot precursors through the production of C 14 H 14 (via dimerization of benzyl radical) and pyrene (through dimerization of indenyl radical).