The effect of catalysts with varying nucleophilic strength on thiol−thioester bond exchange dynamics and concomitant crystallization was studied in a model semicrystalline polymer network. It was found that the characteristic time scale of covalent bond exchange, τ, could be tuned over a ∼10 1 −10 3 s range simply by changing the nucleophilicity of the catalyst. Using isothermal crystallization measurements via differential scanning calorimetry, thermodynamic and kinetic features of crystallization were considered. A depression in melting temperature was observed with increasing bond exchange rate, suggesting a dependence of crystalline organization on network dynamics. Furthermore, a systematic slowing of crystallization kinetics with faster covalent bond exchange rates was observed. Lauritzen−Hoffman analysis showed a near doubling in the barrier for secondary nucleation for dynamic networks, suggesting that that bond exchange slows crystallization by limiting secondary nucleation and further growth. Finally, longitudinal DSC studies reveal a long-term increase in melting temperature for samples held at ambient temperature with bond exchange activated at room temperature, indicating that while bond exchange slows crystallization on short time scales it facilitates isothermal long-term crystal rearrangement and growth on longer time scales.