The kinetics of many proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions cannot be adequately described by stepwise proton and electron transfer. Concerted electron− proton transfer (CPET) is another possibility, but examples exist where stepwise mechanisms are not viable yet there is no compelling evidence for CPET. This study investigates such a reaction, the oxidation of an NH-containing phenylenediamine radical cation, H 2 PD + , in the presence of pyridines in acetonitrile, using CV and UV/vis spectroelectrochemistry. As observed previously, the E 1/2 for the radical oxidation jumps to a considerably more negative potential upon addition of 1 equiv of pyridine. The CV wave broadens but stays chemically reversible. Further addition of pyridine leads to smaller E 1/2 shifts with continued reversibility. Different explanations have been put forth for this behavior; however, this study provides strong evidence that the E 1/2 shift can be completely explained by the overall reaction being H 2 PD + + pyr − e − → HPD + + Hpyr + . Classic stepwise proton−electron transfer cannot explain the reversibility, but it can be explained by a "wedge" scheme mechanism in which electron and proton transfer occurs in a stepwise fashion within the H-bond complex formed as an intermediate in proton transfer. This result points to the important role H-bonding may play in PCET even without CPET.