Effect of Message Approach and Image Size on Pictorial Health Warning Effectiveness on Cigarette Pack in Indonesia: A Mixed Factorial Experiment

Abstract

Background: Cigarette consumption remains high and increasing in Indonesia. The government implemented a pictorial health warnings requirement of 40% cover of the pack (front and back) using fear appeal messages. Objective: Our study aims to assess the effectiveness of cigarette pictorial health warnings by message and size. Methods: We conducted a mixed factorial experiment online study using three messaging approaches (fear vs. guilt vs. financial loss) and two picture sizes (40% vs. 75%) among 209 smoking participants. Sociodemographic variables included gender, education, income, employment status, and marital status. Data analysis used a mixed model ANOVA to see the main effect and interaction effect on dependent variables. For subgroup analysis, we used t-test and one-way ANOVA. All analyzes were in SPSS 22. Results: We found significant differences in the three message types, in which fear and guilt have higher effectiveness than financial loss. By subgroup, the guilt message was more compelling among female smokers and married smokers. The financial loss message was effective among lower-income smokers. We found no difference in pictorial health warning effectiveness by image size, potentially because participants could zoom in/out the cigarette pack image on the screen. Conclusions: Our finding supports more diverse message types in pictorial health warnings in Indonesia and other countries.

Socio-Economic Factors Influencing Sugar-Sweetened Beverages (SSB’s) Consumption in Household of DKI Jakarta Province in 2020

“…Inspired by the cigarette case, three approaches can be used to warn people against excessive consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages: using fear, guilt, and financial loss. These three approaches may have different effectiveness depending on the characteristics of the SSBs consumers [44]. This study aims to serve as a guide for developing focused strategies to decrease the prevalence of NCD by aiming at households that have characteristics with a high tendency to consume SSBs.…”

Do Anti-Smoking Advertisements Influence Students to Quit Smoking?

“…Among the five Pictorial Health Warnings (PHWs), the image depicting lung cancer was identified as the most effective in motivating individuals to quit smoking (Alkaff et al, 2020). Smokers also agreed that the PHW was effective and induced fear and worry (Hall et al, 2019;Yuliati et al, 2021).…”

Exposure to Outdoor Tobacco Advertisements Near Home is Associated with Smoking among Youth in Indonesia

“…Smoking is among the top contributors to deaths and disability globally, as shown by the latest Global Burden of Study 2019 (Vos et al, 2020). In Indonesia, the prevalence of cigarette smoking among adult males (15+ years) was persistently high at 67% in 2018 while that among young males (13-14 years) was increasing to 35.5% in 2019, among the highest in the world (World Health Organization [WHO] 2018; Ministry of Health [MOH] 2020; Hapsari et al, 2020;Yuliati et al, 2021). With a population of over 270 million, the World Health Organization estimated 61.4 million current smokers in…”