“…Thus, in stimulated scattering instabilities, negative ions can raise or lower the instability threshold and the growth rate by affecting plasma waves, the ponderomotive force, and the nonlinear current. [2][3][4][5][6] For filamentation instabilities, a critical level of the pump intensity is reported, where the growth rate dependence on negative ions shows a qualitative change. 7 On the other hand, for parametric instabilities occurring at the critical density layer of the plasma, the conspicuous effect of negative ions is the detuning of the sideband frequency outside the resonance range, rather than the changing of the threshold or the growth rate.…”