Aims/hypothesis We aimed to investigate the role of insulin in regulating human skeletal muscle metabolism in health and diabetes. Methods We conducted a systematic review and metaanalysis of published data that examined changes in skeletal muscle protein synthesis (MPS) and/or muscle protein breakdown (MPB) in response to insulin infusion. Random-effects models were used to calculate weighted mean differences (WMDs), 95% CIs and corresponding p values. Both MPS and MPB are reported in units of nmol (100 ml leg vol.)Results A total of 104 articles were examined in detail. Of these, 44 and 25 studies (including a total of 173 individuals) were included in the systematic review and meta-analysis, respectively. In the overall estimate, insulin did not affect MPS 8.55], p=0.71), but significantly reduced MPB .18], p<0.001). Overall, insulin significantly increased net balance protein acquisition (WMD 20.09 [95% CI 15.93,24.26], p<0.001). Subgroup analysis of the effect of insulin on MPS according to amino acid (AA) delivery was performed using meta-regression analysis. The estimate size (WMD) was significantly different between subgroups based on AA availability (p=0.001). An increase in MPS was observed when AA availability increased (WMD 13.44 [95% CI 4.07,22.81], p<0.01), but not when AA availability was reduced or unchanged. In individuals with diabetes and in the presence of maintained delivery of AA, there was a significant reduction in MPS in response to insulin (WMD −6.67 [95% CI −12.29, −0.66], p<0.05). Conclusions/interpretation This study demonstrates the complex role of insulin in regulating skeletal muscle metabolism. Insulin appears to have a permissive role in MPS in the presence of elevated AAs, and plays a clear role in reducing MPB independent of AA availability.