The mechanism of the reaction between tetraaryl ammonium salts and hydroxide is studied experimentally for different N,N‐diaryl carbazolium salts. The N,N‐diarylcarbazolium salts are designed, synthesized, characterized, and reacted with hydroxide under different conditions. The products of the reactions were directly characterized or isolated when possible and, using different substituents, the reaction mechanisms were compared. An unexpected H/D exchange observed in these salts helped to discard the classical SNAr mechanisms, supporting instead a radical mechanism initiated by a single‐electron transfer from the hydroxide. By understanding the preferred reaction pathways, better quaternary ammonium salts can be designed to withstand aggressive alkaline environments, critical for many practical applications such as anion‐exchange membrane fuel cells.