Effect of Tibiofemoral Rotation Angle on Graft Failure After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Abstract

Background: Coronal and sagittal malalignment of the knee are well-recognized risk factors for failure after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR). However, the effect of axial malalignment on graft survival after ACLR is yet to be determined. Purpose: To evaluate whether increased tibiofemoral rotational malalignment, namely, tibiofemoral rotation angle (TFA) and tibial tubercle–trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance, is associated with graft failure after ACLR. Study Design: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. Methods: In this retrospective matched control study of a single center’s database, 151 patients who underwent revision ACLR because of graft failure (ACLR failure group, defined as symptomatic patients with anterior knee instability and an ACL graft tear appreciated on magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] and confirmed during arthroscopic surgery) were compared with a matched control group of 151 patients who underwent primary ACLR with no evidence of failure after ≥2-year follow-up (intact ACLR group). Patients were matched by sex, age, and meniscal injury during primary ACLR. Axial malalignment was assessed on preoperative MRI through the TFA and the TT-TG distance. Sagittal alignment was measured through the posterior tibial slope on MRI. The optimal TFA cutoff associated with graft failure was identified by a receiver operating characteristic curve. The Kaplan-Meier curve with log-rank analysis was performed to evaluate the influence of the TFA on ACLR longevity. Results: The mean age was 25.7 ± 10.4 years for the ACLR failure group and 25.9 ± 10.0 years for the intact ACLR group. Among all the included patients, 174 (57.6%) were male. In the ACLR failure group, the mean TFA was 5.8°± 4.5° (range, −5° to 16°), while it was 3.0°± 3.3° (range, −3° to 15°) in the intact ACLR group ( P < .001). Neither the TT-TG distance nor the posterior tibial slope presented statistical differences between the groups. The receiver operating characteristic curve suggested an optimal TFA cutoff of 4.5° for graft failure (area under the curve = 0.71; P < .001; sensitivity, 68.2%; specificity, 75.5%). Considering this a threshold, patients who had a TFA ≥4.5° had 6.6 times higher odds of graft failure compared with patients with a TFA <4.5° ( P < .001). Survival analysis demonstrated a 5-year survival rate of 81% in patients with a TFA <4.5°, while it was 44% in those with a TFA ≥4.5° ( P < .001). Conclusion: An increased TFA was associated with increased odds of ACLR failure when the TFA was ≥4.5°. Measuring the TFA in patients with ACL tears undergoing reconstruction may inform the surgeon about additional factors that may require consideration before ACLR for a successful outcome.

Abnormal femoral trochlea morphology is a risk factor for secondary injury of anterior cruciate ligament after reconstruction

“…Several studies have highlighted the relationship between initial ACL injury and knee joint morphology. [ 10 , 11 ] Factors such as an increased posterior slope of the tibial plateau, femoral intercondylar fossa stenosis, height mismatch of the tibial intercondylar crest, and abnormal femoral trochlear shape have been identified as risk factors for initial ACL injury. Some of these factors, such as the increased posterior slope of the tibial plateau, femoral intercondylar fossa stenosis, and height mismatch of the tibial intercondylar crest, have also been linked to the occurrence of secondary injuries after ACL reconstruction.…”