Effect of type and amount of dietary carbohydrate on biomarkers of glucose homeostasis and C reactive protein in overweight or obese adults: results from the OmniCarb trial

Abstract

ObjectiveThe glycemic index (GI) of dietary carbohydrate is thought to affect glucose homeostasis. Recently, the Effect of Amount and Type of Dietary Carbohydrates on Risk for Cardiovascular Heart Disease and Diabetes Study (OmniCarb) trial reported that a low-GI diet did not improve insulin sensitivity. We conducted this ancillary study of the OmniCarb trial to determine the effects of GI and carbohydrate content on glucose homeostasis and inflammation.Research design and methodsOmniCarb was a randomized cross-over feeding study conducted in overweight or obese adults without diabetes (N=163). Participants were fed each of 4 diets for 5 weeks with 2-week washout periods. Weight was held constant. Diets were: high GI (GI≥65) with high carbohydrate (58% kcal), low GI (GI≤45) with low carbohydrate (40% kcal), low GI with high carbohydrate, and high GI with low carbohydrate. We measured glycated albumin (GA), fructosamine, and high sensitivity C reactive protein (CRP) at baseline and following each dietary period. These biomarkers were compared within-person between diets.ResultsThe study population was 52% female and 50% black. Mean age was 53 (SD, 11) years; mean body mass index was 32 (SD 6) kg/m2. Reducing GI had no effect on GA or fructosamine, but increased fasting glucose in the setting of a high-carbohydrate diet (+2.2 mg/dL; p=0.02). Reducing carbohydrate content decreased GA in the setting of a high-GI diet (−0.2%; p=0.03) and decreased fructosamine in the setting of a low-GI diet (−4 µmol/L; p=0.003). Reducing carbohydrate while simultaneously increasing GI significantly reduced both GA (−0.2%; p=0.04) and fructosamine (−4 µmol/L; p=0.009). Neither reducing GI nor amount of carbohydrate affected insulin or CRP.ConclusionsReducing carbohydrate, regardless of high or low GI, decreased GA and fructosamine. This suggests that reducing carbohydrate content, rather than GI, is a better strategy for lowering glycemia in adults at risk for diabetes.Trial registration numberNCT00608049.

Low glycaemic index diets as an intervention for obesity: a systematic review and meta‐analysis

“…These articles were then subjected to inclusion or exclusion by application of the full‐text inclusion criteria. We included 109 study arms from 101 individual articles (Table ) . Studies varied in length from 1 week to 104 weeks.…”

A Global Perspective on White Rice Consumption and Risk of Type 2 Diabetes

“…In a subgroup with the metabolic syndrome, parboiled brown rice consumption reduced HbA 1c levels compared with white rice in a crossover trial in India (22). Low-GI varieties of rice also warrant consideration, but results from trials in people without diabetes suggest that reducing carbohydrate intake through replacement with unsaturated fat is more likely to improve glucose metabolism than GI reduction (23,24).…”

Effects of carbohydrate quality and amount on plasma lactate: results from the OmniCarb trial

“…Clinical care/Education/Nutrition carbohydrate amount nor GI improved insulin sensitivity or intermediate-term markers of glucose homeostasis, [7][8][9] leading some to question the role of GI, carbohydrate amount, and dietary carbohydrates in general in the development of diabetes. 6 However, because OmniCarb was conducted in people with intact regulatory systems for blood glucose, blood glucose may not have been sensitive enough to detect short-term dietary effects on glucose homeostasis.…”