Effect of visual distraction and auditory feedback on patient effort during robot-assisted movement training after stroke

Abstract

BackgroundPracticing arm and gait movements with robotic assistance after neurologic injury can help patients improve their movement ability, but patients sometimes reduce their effort during training in response to the assistance. Reduced effort has been hypothesized to diminish clinical outcomes of robotic training. To better understand patient slacking, we studied the role of visual distraction and auditory feedback in modulating patient effort during a common robot-assisted tracking task.MethodsFourteen participants with chronic left hemiparesis from stroke, five control participants with chronic right hemiparesis and fourteen non-impaired healthy control participants, tracked a visual target with their arms while receiving adaptive assistance from a robotic arm exoskeleton. We compared four practice conditions: the baseline tracking task alone; tracking while also performing a visual distracter task; tracking with the visual distracter and sound feedback; and tracking with sound feedback. For the distracter task, symbols were randomly displayed in the corners of the computer screen, and the participants were instructed to click a mouse button when a target symbol appeared. The sound feedback consisted of a repeating beep, with the frequency of repetition made to increase with increasing tracking error.ResultsParticipants with stroke halved their effort and doubled their tracking error when performing the visual distracter task with their left hemiparetic arm. With sound feedback, however, these participants increased their effort and decreased their tracking error close to their baseline levels, while also performing the distracter task successfully. These effects were significantly smaller for the participants who used their non-paretic arm and for the participants without stroke.ConclusionsVisual distraction decreased participants effort during a standard robot-assisted movement training task. This effect was greater for the hemiparetic arm, suggesting that the increased demands associated with controlling an affected arm make the motor system more prone to slack when distracted. Providing an alternate sensory channel for feedback, i.e., auditory feedback of tracking error, enabled the participants to simultaneously perform the tracking task and distracter task effectively. Thus, incorporating real-time auditory feedback of performance errors might improve clinical outcomes of robotic therapy systems.

Does providing real-time augmented feedback affect the performance of repeated lower limb loading to exhaustion?

“…In this manner, during a continuous and regular task such as hopping, it may have been possible to accurately maintain the cadence and target hop height, since focussed attention is not required to follow audible feedback. 25 The findings of the current study may not be extrapolated to other populations such as older adults or children as it has been demonstrated that these populations have relatively poor motor performance compared to young adults. 26 Further, task difficulty 27-30 has been closely associated with achieving appropriate postural control while performing a concurrent cognitive or motor task.…”

The Effects of Integrated Visual and Auditory Stimulus Speed on Gait of Individuals with Stroke

“…They were randomly chosen using sealed envelopes before the start of the intervention from among those who understood the study and showed a clear will to participate in it. We chose those hemiparetic patients who had experienced a stroke at least 6 months earlier and were able to walk more than 10 m independently; who did not have visual impairment, hearing problems, and surgical and mental disorders affecting walking; whose scores on the Mini-Mental State Examination were more than 24; and whose Brunnstrom stages were more than 4 4) .…”

“…Recently, auditory stimulation [4][5][6] and visual stimulation 4,7,8) have been used to improve the gait ability of stroke patients. Rhythmic auditory stimulation (RAS) is a type of neurologic music therapy that uses rhythmic sensory stimuli.…”

Upper-Extremity Rehabilitation Robot RehabRoby: Methodology, Design, Usability and Validation

“…In order to include cognitive processing within the rehabilitation tasks, we asked the subjects to follow a visually presented desired motion trajectory that is likely to command their concentration. It has been shown that therapy may be more successful if it informs patients of their progress toward their goals [33], [34]. Subjects are asked to pay attention to tracking the desired trajectory as accurately as possible, which keeps them focused on the task.…”