Effective communication of public health guidance to emergency department clinicians in the setting of emerging incidents: a qualitative study and framework

Abstract

BackgroundEvidence to inform communication between emergency department clinicians and public health agencies is limited. In the context of diverse, emerging public health incidents, communication is urgent, as emergency department clinicians must implement recommendations to protect themselves and the public. The objectives of this study were to: explore current practices, barriers and facilitators at the local level for communicating public health guidance to emergency department clinicians in emerging public health incidents; and develop a framework that promotes effective communication of public health guidance to clinicians during emerging incidents.MethodsA qualitative study was conducted using semi-structured interviews with 26 key informants from emergency departments and public health agencies in Ontario, Canada. Data were analyzed inductively and the analytic approach was guided by concepts of complexity theory.ResultsEmergent themes corresponded to challenges and strategies for effective communication of public health guidance. Important challenges related to the coordination of communication across institutions and jurisdictions, and differences in work environments across sectors. Strategies for effective communication were identified as the development of partnerships and collaboration, attention to specific methods of communication used, and the importance of roles and relationship-building prior to an emerging public health incident. Following descriptive analysis, a framework was developed that consists of the following elements: 1) Anticipate; 2) Invest in building relationships and networks; 3) Establish liaison roles and redundancy; 4) Active communication; 5) Consider and respond to the target audience; 6) Leverage networks for coordination; and 7) Acknowledge and address uncertainty. The qualities inherent in local relationships cut across framework elements.ConclusionsThis research indicates that relationships are central to effective communication between public health agencies and emergency department clinicians at the local level. Our framework which is grounded in qualitative evidence focuses on strategies to promote effective communication in the emerging public health incident setting and may be useful in informing practice.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12913-017-2220-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Public health emergency preparedness for infectious disease emergencies: a scoping review of recent evidence

“…For example, frameworks that described surveillance and laboratory testing activities were included, whereas a focus on measures relevant only to the federal level in Canada such as travel quarantine would be excluded. Infectious disease emergency was defined as an incident, outbreak or threat with the potential to overwhelm or otherwise disrupt routine local capacities due to their timing, scale or unpredictability [ 16 , 25 , 26 ]. Only English-language records were included.…”

Vicarious Trauma Experienced by Health Care Providers Involved in Traumatic Childbirths: A Meta-Synthesis

“…Organizations should recognize the consequences of ineffective communication on patient safety and therefore invest in resources to improve communication and team collaboration among health care providers. Such resources may include standardized communication workflow, effective communication workshops, and team simulations (Foronda et al, 2016; Khan et al, 2017; Moreira & French, 2019). For the L&D nurses who were deeply traumatized by the abusive deliveries and overwhelmed by the sense of helplessness in raising their concerns, there should be communication channels such as whistleblowing where they can make a disclosure of their experiences of professional wrongdoings without any repercussions (Berry, 2004).…”

What is the current state of public health system preparedness for infectious disease emergencies? A scoping review

“…For example, frameworks which described surveillance and laboratory testing activities were included, whereas a focus on measures relevant only to the federal level in Canada such as travel quarantine would be excluded. Infectious disease emergency was defined as an incident, outbreak or threat with the potential to overwhelm or otherwise disrupt routine local capacities due to their timing, scale or unpredictability [21][22][23]. Only English-language records were included.…”