Effectiveness and Efficiency of Non-drug Therapy Among Community-Dwelling Adults With Hypertension in China: A Protocol for Network Meta-Analysis and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis

Abstract

Introduction: The Chinese government has established a nationwide community-based chronic disease management program since 2009 with hypertension a vital part of it. Though drugs have been proven effective with hypertensive patients, they bring economic burden as well, especially for those who with elevated blood pressure and are potentially eligible for national programs. When the effectiveness of pharmacotherapy-only interventions remains uncertain on these patients, non-pharmacological interventions have demonstrated non-inferior effectiveness and may have economic advantages. To date, there rarely are evidences on the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of non-pharmacological treatment in comparison with pharmacological interventions for patients with varying severity of blood pressure. This study aims to propose a study for a network meta-analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis to explore what kind of intervention is potentially effective and cost-effective to four specific patient groups, stage I-III hypertensive patients and patients with elevated blood pressure, and to provide recommendations for hypertensive management to Chinese decision makers.Methods: We will systematically search databases (MEDLINE, PubMed, Cochrane Library, etc.,) for randomized controlled trials and observational studies with qualified study design in recent decade that assess the effectiveness of non-pharmacological, pharmacological, or combined intervention aimed at adult populations who are diagnosed with the above four types of hypertension in China. The effectiveness outcomes will include changes in SBP/DBP, rate of comorbidities, mortality, and health related quality of life. We will use network meta-analysis to compare and rank effectiveness of different interventions. Subgroup analyses and meta-regression analyses will be performed to analyze and explain heterogeneity. The economic outcome will include cost-effectiveness based on simulation results from Markov models. Under study perspective of Chinese health system, life-time direct cost will be included.Discussion: This study aims to compare and rank the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of pharmacological, non-pharmacological and combined interventions for stage I–III hypertensive patients and those who with elevated blood pressure. Compared to existing studies, this comprehensive synthesis of relevant evidences will influence future practice with better efficiency and generalizability for community-based hypertensive management programs in China. The study might also be valuable for other low- and middle-income countries to find their own solutions.PROSPERO registration number: CRD42020151518

Short-term efficacy of non-pharmacological interventions for global population with elevated blood pressure: A network meta-analysis

“…This research was reported following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) checklist (26). This research was registered with PROSPERO (registration number: CRD42020151518) and the protocol has been published (27).…”

“…However, blinding and allocation concealment would be difficult to achieve in NPIs. Therefore, we would make particular note of articles that did not involve blinding and allocation concealment but had valuable data (27).…”

Interventions for reducing blood pressure in prehypertension: A meta-analysis

“…However, it is the high calorie food consumption and sedentary lifestyle habits that conflict with LSM and affect adherence to implementation in people with PHT. A number of studies are now emerging that provide evidence for pharmacological treatment, but long-term drug use places a financial burden on the healthcare system and families ( 12 ). Previous studies have included BP across both PHT and HT populations, and fewer studies have discussed pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions together.…”

Modeling Posttreatment Prognosis of Skin Lesions in Patients With Psoriasis in China

“…We modeled the posttreatment prognosis of skin lesions using transition diagrams among skin lesion scales. A transition diagram is a widely used tool for assessing disease development in chronic diseases [23][24][25] and models the probabilities of transitioning among health stages over time. 26 It is useful for understanding the course of diseases and the chances of getting better.…”