Effectiveness of Multimedia Pedagogical Agents Predicted by Diverse Theories: a Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Multimedia pedagogical agents are on-screen characters that allow users to navigate or learn in multimedia environments. Several agents' characteristics may moderate their instructional effectiveness, including appearance, gender, nonverbal communication, motion, and voice. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis to test hypotheses from diverse theories predicting the effects of these agents' characteristics. We tested predictions of cognitive load theory, cognitive theory of multimedia learning, computers are social actors, social agency theory, uncanny valley, and the action observation network. Our meta-analysis of 32 effect sizes (N = 2104) revealed a small overall effect (g+ = 0.20), showing that learning with multimedia pedagogical agents was more effective than learning without these agents. As predicted by the redundancy effect of cognitive load theory and the coherence principle of cognitive theory of multimedia learning, 2D agents (g+ = 0.38) tended to be more effective than 3D agents (g+ = 0.11). As predicted by the computers are social actors hypothesis, most of the agents' characteristics, including nonverbal communication, motion, and voice, appeared not to moderate their effectiveness. We conclude that multimedia pedagogical agents help learning through multimedia, and that students may be able to learn similarly from different types of agents.Keywords Multimedia animated pedagogical agent . Cognitive load theory and cognitive theory of multimedia learning . Computers are social actors and social agency theory . Uncanny valley and action observation network . Meta-analysis

When Refutation and Deep Reasoning Questions Lose Their Edge: The Case of Short, Narrated Videos

“…Future work is needed in the area to examine why this may occur, and if the results found in this study are replicable in different contexts. It is also worth examining if the presence of the virtual human may have any interaction with the effectiveness of the different narrative styles, since the mere presence of a visually-present agent can influence learning (Castro-Alonso et al, 2021; Schroeder et al, 2013).…”

“…These characters can take many forms, but are often broadly referred to as pedagogical agents when they are designed to support the learning process (Sinatra et al, 2021). Meta-analyses have shown that pedagogical agents can aid learning (Castro-Alonso et al, 2021; Schroeder et al, 2013) but critical questions have arisen, such as how to most effectively design pedagogical agents (Heidig & Clarebout, 2011).…”

The Impact of Emotional Feedback and Elaborated Feedback of a Pedagogical Agent on Multimedia Learning

“…Pedagogical agents are animated anthropomorphic characters employed in the digital learning environment to convey information and enhance motivation by simulating social interaction with learners (Kim et al, 2007 ; Castro-Alonso et al, 2021 ). There are two propositions of theories to explain how PA affects multimedia learning.…”

The Development of Virtual Worlds as a Tool for Providing Virtual Grocery Store Tours

“…While the presence of an avatar is not necessary to communicate information in a virtual world (information can be provided merely by a voiceover), the use of an avatar may have positive effects on the motivation to learn [36,37]. Indeed, a recent meta-analysis found that learning with avatars was more effective than learning without these agents [38]. The characteristics of the avatar should be considered when designing a virtual grocery store tour as it may influence the client's emotional response or the effectiveness of the program [39].…”