Effectiveness of non-immersive virtual reality in the management of procedure-related pain in preschool children: a randomized clinical trial

Abstract

ObjectiveTo assess the effectiveness of non-immersive virtual reality as a pain-distraction measure in children between the ages of 3-5 years undergoing painful injection procedures in an outpatient setting. DesignWe carried out a randomized, unmasked clinical trial in children undergoing venipuncture or intramuscular injection procedures. Patients were randomized to a distraction virtual reality video or standard care. After the procedure, three independent observers (parents, researchers, nursing staff) rated pain on the LLANTO pain scale. ResultsWe recruited 122 subjects, half of which were randomized to virtual reality. The median age was of approximately 5 years and the sample was balanced with regards to sex. Agreement between raters was high for all three types of observers, with Cohen Kappas over 0.79 in all cases. Bivariate analysis showed reductions in the risk of obtaining higher scores in the LLANTO scale. Linear regression models showed a reduction of approximately 3 points in the scale, regardless of the type of observer. These models were adjusted for sex, age, kind of procedure, use of prior analgesia, and recruitment center. ConclusionsNon-immersive virtual reality is an effective adjunctive therapy for the reduction of pain in children undergoing painful injection procedures in an outpatient setting. This strategy may be used to improve the quality of care in pediatric outpatient services.Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identi er: NCT03985930 What Is KnownThe use of immersive virtual reality (VR) has been described as an effective adjunctive distraction method during painful procedures in children over 5 years.What is new: The utility of non-immersive VR in children below that age is not yet clear. This randomized clinical trial comparing non-immersive VR vs. standard care showed an average reduction of three points in the LLANTO pain scale favoring non-immersive VR. Non-immersive VR is an effective and inexpensive non-pharmacological technique that reduces fear and pain in pediatric patients.