Effectiveness of Student Tutors in Problem-Based Learning of Undergraduate Medical Education

Abstract

Problem-based learning (PBL) is a teaching and learning method designed to develop clinical reasoning skills. Tutor performance in PBL affects both the process and outcome of student learning. In this study, we investigated the factors that influence the evaluation by undergraduate students on the performance of tutors in medical education. From April 2009 to February 2010, 49 PBL sessions were conducted for 191 3rd-and 4th-year medical students at Saga Medical School in Japan. Twenty-nine 6th-year students and 205 faculty members tutored these sessions. After each session, students evaluated their tutor by a Likert scale. This evaluation score was dichotomized and used as the dependent variable. A multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to assess the contribution of student's gender and year level (3rd or 4th), the tutor's gender and background, and the quality of the case scenario to evaluation ratings. A total of 4,469 responses were analyzed. Male student and tutor background were associated with excellent tutor evaluation. Concerning the tutor background, compared with basic scientists, the 6th-year students and content-expert clinicians were positively associated with excellent tutor evaluations (ORs of 1.

Evaluation of a Problem Based Learning Curriculum Using Content Analysis

“…Every group received equivalent tutors, either from student tutor or faculty tutor. This study found that student gender, quality of case scenarios and tutor backgrounds were correlated with "excellent scores" in tutor performances [9]. This finding is in line with the previous researches by Dolmans, et.al.…”

Evaluation of problem-based learning curriculum implementation in a clerkship rotation of a newly established African medical training institution: lessons from the University of Botswana

“…01). Similar findings were reported in a Japanese study where a rating of 'excellent' regarding case scenarios was associated with excellent tutor evaluations (OR of 12.43 [95% CI: 10.28-15.03) [14]. …”

Assessing the Effectiveness of Problem-Based Learning of Preventive Medicine Education in China

“…PBL is defined as a student-centered pedagogy in which participants are allocated in groups of up to 8 persons under non-directive tutors and given tasks or challenges that reflect situations relevant to the working environments they will experience2. In this way, the learners are empowered to integrate theory and practice, and apply knowledge and skills to develop a viable solution to the problem34. PBL represents a paradigm shift from traditional pedagogy, which is more often lecture-based learning (LBL).…”