During a mark-recapture study of Parnassius mnemosyne butterfly, we recorded incidence of females bearing or not bearing sphragis, a waxy structure delivered by males during copulation and preventing subsequent inseminations by other males. Despite the common belief that sphragis ensures monopolisation of females, we observed that 74 out of 579 marked females did not bear sphragis at a time of capture. We also recorded five instances of sphragis loss and one female that lost and subsequently re-acquired the structure. A sphragis thus does not represent a reliable indicator of females' mating status in P. mnemosyne. Repeated inseminations occur in this species and might buffer some extremely small populations against loss of within-population genetic variation. However, the proportion of sphragis-free females increased with season, and it remains to be ascertained to what extend is this caused by sphragis loss in previously inseminated females, and to which this is an outcome of earlier reproductive asynchrony, or early emergence of males that renders some of the late-emerging females unmated.