Effects of Asynchronous Stressors on the Eastern Oyster (Crassostrea virginica)

Abstract

With intensifying global change ecologists work to understand the effects of anthropogenic and environmental stressors on organisms. Importantly, prior stress can influence population response to later stress. This is often seen in population response to acute stress during extreme events, which may occur after exposure to other chronic environmental stressors. However, experiments on the effects of asynchrony in which stresses are imposed at different times on organisms are rare. I reviewed this small but growing body of literature and show how results in studies incorporating asynchrony often differ from those that examine the effects of multiple stressors imposed on organisms at the same time. In particular, I found that asynchrony rarely leads to additive effects, but rather elicited responses of cross-tolerance (mitigation of latter stress) or cross-susceptibility (exacerbation of the latter stress). Additionally, the majority of asynchronous stressor studies were conducted in North America and Europe and were rare in the rest of the world. I also conducted an experiment on Eastern oysters (Crassostrea virginica), for which there are few asynchronous stressor studies. In Galveston Bay, Texas, the hurricane season begins in May, following mild spring water temperatures, but continues through late summer months, when water temperatures can reach 32°C. I asked if oysters respond differently to hurricane-level low-salinity stress after periods of elevated late summer temperatures relative to more standard, earlyseason conditions. I exposed newly settled oyster spat to early-season (24°C) or lateseason high temperatures (32°C) for one month followed by an acute low salinity (1 ppt) disturbance for 10 days (versus control). Oysters experienced the highest mortality iii (46%) when high-temperature and low salinity stresses were imposed simultaneously with no prior conditioning. This was significantly different from oysters under asynchronous stressor treatments, which saw only 4% mortality. Additionally, prior thermal stress mitigated some of the negative effects of subsequent osmotic stress leading to significantly lower mortalities (4%) compared to treatments under acute salinity stress without prior heat exposure (16%). Results suggest that incorporating temporal dynamics, rather than simply crossing multiple stressors simultaneously, can have important consequences for our understanding of impacts from extreme events on early, important life stages of organisms.Masami Fujiwara, for their support through the course of my master's thesis. Additionally, I could not have seen my experiment through to completion without the help of Katie St. Clair and the Sea Life Facility. Thank you also to Dr. Scott Rikard at the Auburn Island Shellfish Laboratory for shipping me oyster spat and providing me with husbandry knowledge. A special thank you to my lab members Emily Hubbard and Melissa Ciesielski. Their support during my experiment was unparalleled. Additional thanks to Ume, Olivia, Candace, Janelle, Rayna, and Stephani...

Hatchery capacity needed to support large‐scale Atlantic surfclam fishery enhancement

“…Therefore, this research could be extended to look further into other fishing sectors, marine species and geographical locations. Shellfish aquaculture can provide a variety of ecosystem services, such as habitat provisioning (Shinn et al., 2021; Theuerkauf et al., 2021), water filtration (Barr et al., In Press; Zu Ermgassen et al., 2012), nutrient cycling (Humphries et al., 2016; Kellogg et al., 2013; Lunstrum et al., 2018) and sediment stabilization (Donaldi et al., 2013). Advances in the ability to quantify and value these services may increase opportunities associated with green financing and investment (O'Shea et al., 2019).…”

The effect of single versus successive warm summers on an intertidal community

“…Even if recovery can occur between stressors, an initial stressor may engender susceptibility to subsequent stressors (Marshall and Sinclair 2015, Siegle et al 2018, Jackson et al 2021, Sun et al 2022, perhaps by eroding the energy stores available for coping with secondary stressors. Alternatively, if an initial stressor increases performance or induces the production of protective metabolites, organisms may instead be more robust to subsequent stressors (Marshall and Sinclair 2015, Brooks and Crowe 2019, MacLennan and Vinebrooke 2021, Agrawal and Jurgens 2023. Manipulating the timing of stressors, in addition to their intensity, is key to better understanding their ecological effects.…”

Timing determines zooplankton community responses to multiple stressors

“…For example, lake nitrogen levels experienced significant temporal fluctuation due to extreme floods (Minor et al., 2014); and summer chloride concentrations in streams fluctuated temporally due to precipitation events (Lawson & Jackson, 2021). These temporal fluctuations in intensity can cause stressors to be decoupled in time (e.g., asynchronous thermal and pH stresses in Kline et al., 2015 and low‐salinity and elevated temperature stresses in Agrawal & Jurgens, 2023).…”