“…For laboratory incubation studies, biochar decreases (Spokas, Koskinen, Baker, & Reicosky, 2009) or increases (Stewart, Zheng, Botte, & Cotrufo, 2013;Zheng, Stewart, & Cotrufo, 2012) CO 2 emissions. However comparisons of laboratory incubation studies and field studies show that CO 2 emission responses to biochar are consistently higher in incubation studies than in field or greenhouse studies (He et al, 2017;Shen, Zhu, Cheng, Yue, & Li, 2017). The response of exoenzymes to biochar amendments have largely been conducted in laboratory incubations with variable results (Awad, Blagodatskaya, Ok, & Kuzyakov, 2012;Bailey, Fansler, Smith, & Bolton, 2011;Demisie, Liu, & Zhang, 2014;Ouyang, Tang, Yu, & Zhang, 2014).…”