Effects of Concussion on the Relative Contributions of Sensorimotor Memories during Adaptation to Unpredictable Spring-Like Loads

Abstract

We examined the extent to which concussion impacts how implicit sensorimotor memories are used to compensate for changes in hand-held loads during goal-directed reaching. Recently concussed individuals performed computerized cognition tests and a robotic test of sensorimotor adaptation on three occasions: as soon as possible after injury; after clearance to return to activity; three months after injury. Non-concussed individuals (controls) were tested at inter-session intervals mimicking concussed group intervals. During robotic testing, subjects grasped the handle of a horizontal planar robot while reaching repeatedly to a target. The robot exerted spring-like forces that changed unpredictably between trials; this allowed us to estimate contributions of implicit sensorimotor memories to trial-by-trial performance by fitting a computational model to the time series of reach errors and robot forces. Symptom severity varied considerably within the concussed group at the first session. Computerized cognition tests revealed longer reaction times in the concussed group relative to control group in Session 1 only. Concussed subjects likewise had slower reaction time in the reaching task during the first but not later sessions. Computational modeling found abnormally high values of effective limb compliance in concussed individuals relative to the control group in the first session only, but did not find group differences in how sensorimotor memories contribute to reach adaptation in any session. Analysis of control group models identified a practice effect affecting the memory coefficients that may have masked initial effects of concussion on how implicit memories contribute to sensorimotor adaptation. Although a practice effect and a heterogeneous concussed cohort preclude strong conclusions, our findings suggest procedural improvements that may decrease the robotic test's sensitivity to practice effects and increase its sensitivity to concussion-related changes in how implicit memories contribute to sensorimotor adaptation to unpredictable hand-held loads during reaching.