This article summarizes available literature regarding the utilization of probiotic and synbiotics in liver transplant (LTX) recipients, reviewing efficacy in both decreasing infectious complications and immunomodulation, as well as exploring safety concerns. Data suggest that the use of probiotics containing Lactobacillus spp, either alone or in combination with prebiotics (referred to as synbiotics), may be effective in reducing infectious complications after LTX, a major contributor to graft loss, hospital length of stay, and mortality. Literature evaluating the use of probiotics to induce tolerance, reduce rejection, and prevent damage associated with ischemia-reperfusion injury is limited to animal models but compelling, as it suggests the use of probiotics may augment deleterious immune-mediated processes in this population. While the benefits of probiotics should be weighed against potential risks, these concerns are largely theoretical in the LTX recipient, with the majority of evidence extrapolated from case reports in other immunosuppressed populations. Based on available literature, it may be prudent to avoid products containing Saccharomyces sp, as these were not used in the efficacy studies, and the majority of the adverse event reporting stems from the use of products containing this organism. Further evaluation of the safety and efficacy of probiotic therapy is warranted. Studies specifically designed to elucidate the optimal product and initiation scenario and delineate safety in this population are needed to allow expanded use of this inexpensive, relatively nontoxic, and potentially beneficial therapeutic option after LTX.