IntroductionThe maintenance of harmful alcohol use implies reiterated decisions to consume alcohol in concrete drinking occasions. These decisions are often made despite an intention to quit or reduce alcohol consumption. Although there is quite a large body of evidence on neural responsivity to alcohol cues or neural mechanisms of general decision-making capacities in individuals with alcohol use disorders, the neural processes during real drinking decisions remain largely unclear.Dual-process models of addiction 1,2 state the importance of 2 distinct but interacting systems during decisions for and against alcohol consumption. On the one hand, a reward system (also referred to as an impulsive, motivational, or reflexive system) has been implicated in the immediate emotional assessment of stimuli and automatic (approach) behaviour. On the other hand, a cognitive control system (also referred to as a deliberative or reflective system) that modulates this primary assessment by integration of higher-order considerations, such as long-term effects of a possible decision, has been suggested. In theory, both a hyperactive reward system and an impaired control system may contribute to addictive behaviour. Indeed, behavioural and neuroimaging data suggest alterations in both systems in individuals with substance use disorders.Alcohol-dependent or heavily drinking individuals show subjective craving 3 and automatic approach tendencies 4,5 when confronted with alcoholic drinks, and a substantial body of literature suggests that such addiction-related behaviour is
Background:The maintenance of harmful alcohol use can be considered a reiterated decision in favour of alcohol in concrete drinking occasions. These decisions are often made despite an intention to quit or reduce alcohol consumption. We tested if a hyperactive reward system and/or an impaired cognitive control system contribute to such unfavourable decision-making. Methods: In this fMRI study, men with modest to harmful drinking behaviour, which was measured using the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT), repeatedly made decisions between alcoholic and nonalcoholic drinks. Based on prior individual ratings, decision pairs were created with an alcoholic decision option considered more desirable but less beneficial by the participant. By correlating AUDIT scores with brain activation during decision-making, we determined areas explicitly related to pro-alcohol decisions in men with greater drinking severity. Results: Thirty-eight men participated in our study. Behaviourally, we found a positive correlation between AUDIT scores and the number of decisions for desired alcoholic drinks compared with beneficial nonalcoholic drinks. The fMRI results show that AUDIT scores were positively associated with activation in areas associated with reward and motivation processing (i.e., ventral striatum, amygdala, medial prefrontal cortex) during decisions favouring a desired, nonbeneficial alcoholic drink. Conversely, we did not find hypoactivation in areas assoc...