“…Determining critical N deposition loads on specific habitats must combine manipulation experiments mimicking the frequency and temporal nature of the dry and wet N deposition at levels low enough to include the range of known N deposition, with observations on biodiversity, ecosystem processes and indicator species along anthropogenic N deposition gradients (e.g., Bobbink et al, 2010). Many manipulation experiments have been conducted to study potential impacts of N addition on ecosystems such as temperate grasslands (e.g., Morecroft et al, 1994;Horswill et al, 2008), Mediterranean shrublands (e.g., Vourlitis et al, 2009;Dias et al, 2011), deserts (e.g., Allen et al, 2009;Schneider and Allen, 2012), and the boreal tundra (e.g., Nemergut et al, 2008;DeLuca et al, 2007). However, the approach has some drawbacks, such as the limited number of years that it is practical to maintain such experiments (Duprè et al, 2010).…”