“…The few published articles that do examine TNC impacts on energy and the environment are constrained to survey methods or limited geographies, and, when taken together, reach inferences and conclusions that initially may appear inconsistent with one another. Previous analyses of TNC effects on vehicle ownership, for example, have found either a decrease in vehicle ownership ( Ward et al., 2019 ) or that “ridesourcing probably did not influence car ownership behavior” ( Rayle et al., 2016 ). Considered with appropriate context and constraints, these findings are not necessarily inconsistent (the decline in vehicle ownership was modeled at the U.S. state level, while the no-effect finding was based on a survey specific to San Francisco, CA), but their differences point to the need for a coherent framework within which to interpret such findings and their associated implications.…”