Background/Objectives: The extracellular calcium-sensing receptor (CaSR) is a multifunctional receptor proposed as a possible drug target for inflammatory bowel disease. We showed previously that CaSR inhibition with NPS 2143, a negative allosteric modulator of the CaSR, somewhat ameliorated the symptoms of chemically induced severe colitis in mice. However, it was unclear whether the potential of CaSR inhibition to reduce colitis may have been overshadowed by the severity of the induced inflammation in our previous study. Therefore, we tested if CaSR inhibition could prevent medium-grade colitis. Methods: Female BALB/c mice were treated with NPS 2143 or a vehicle prior to the induction of colitis with 2.5% DSS. On the day of sacrifice, colons and plasma were collected. The histology score was determined based on hematoxylin-eosin-stained sections. Mucin content, proliferation (Ki67), and immune cell infiltration (CD3 and CD20) were quantified based on immunostainings. Gene expression was measured by RT-qPCR. Results: Treatment with NPS 2143 had no effect on the clinical symptom score of the mice. However, the colons of the mice in the treated group were significantly longer (p < 0.05), and NPS 2143 significantly reduced colon ulceration (p < 0.05). The treatment also significantly reduced the expression of COX2 in the proximal colon and IL-22 in the distal colon. The proliferation of cells in the lymph nodes was significantly lower after the treatment, but no difference was observed in the epithelial cells. Conclusions: In summary, while NPS 2143 had an anti-inflammatory effect on medium-grade colitis, this effect appeared to be milder than in severe colitis, as observed previously, indicating that the effectiveness of CaSR inhibition as an anti-inflammatory measure in the colon is proportional to disease severity.